Ameda Breast Pump Vs Medela Pump In Style

Are you trying to decide between Ameda Breast Pump Vs Medela Pump In Style?

Then let us help you decide which is best for you and your baby: Ameda Breast Pump vs Medela!

If you want to express breast milk regularly, investing in a high-quality breast pump is well worth the money, and while this is not true for all baby supplies, the more money you pay, the more likely you will acquire high-quality equipment.

But with so many products out there, it can be pretty overwhelming. Choosing the right one for you may be difficult as every pump seems to offer different features or pumping experiences. 

To help you on your pumping journey, we have reviewed two of the most popular breast pumps out there – Medela Pump In Style vs Ameda Mya.

Here we will cover all of the essential features of these products, and give a pros and cons list, so you can easily see which one is right for you. 

And if you love this Ameda Mya pump vs Medela Pump In Style breast pump comparisons guide, make sure to check out our guides on Motif Luna vs Medela Pump In Style, Ameda Mya vs Spectra S2, and Medela Pump In Style vs Spectra S2. Or even our Ameda Mya Breast Pump reviews.

This post contains affiliate links. See our full disclosure here

Ameda Breast Pump vs Medela Pump In Style

Let’s dive in and take a look how the Medela pump in style vs Ameda Mya compare.

All About Ameda

The Ameda Mya is known for being small and lightweight whilst still offering hospital-grade suction. Not only is the motor powerful, but it is also very quiet.

The motor runs at 45db which means that it won’t wake up your sleeping baby- perfect for nighttime pumping!

The only issue with nighttime pumping is that the buttons are not backlit which could make them difficult to see in the dark, yet the LED screen is very bright which could be a problem. 

It has an ergonomic design that feels very comfortable. It weighs just half a pound so you will be impressed at how light it is.

It is also small enough to be transported easily, making it simple to take on the go with you.

The battery is rechargeable and can run for two hours, so you can easily take the breast pump with you on a day out and be able to use it several times without needing a power source.

The pump is very easy to assemble. Once you are familiar with the set up you will be able to set it up in less than 30 seconds.

The variable rate control dial allows you to easily adjust the speed and direction of the vacuum.

The pump has 5 different massage modes to encourage the milk flow and 10 expression modes to extract the milk.

This is designed to imitate the nursing habits of a baby whilst enabling you to customize the pumping cycle to suit your body. The Ameda Mya has a maximum pumping capacity of 250mmHG. 

The Ameda Mya pump comes with various bottles and removable cups. It can hold 8 ounces of milk at any one time which should be plenty for most mothers. The pump has a closed system which makes it very easy to clean. 

All you need to do is disassemble the pump and wash any parts that come into contact with the milk in warm water and soap. Some parts of the pump are dishwasher safe which makes the cleaning process even easier. 

Pros

• Size – The breast pump is small and lightweight which makes it comfortable to use and easy to transport. 
• Power – Despite the small size, this breast pump has a powerful motor that produces an efficient flow rate. 
• Noise – The motor runs quietly which is ideal for nighttime pumping and discreet pumping. 
• Simple – The pump is easy to assemble and disassemble and is very simple to use 
• Cleaning – The pump has a closed system which makes it easy to clean, and some of the parts are dishwasher safe 

Cons

• Storage – The Ameda Mya does not come with a storage bag to keep all of the accessories in. Some retailers offer a bundle that does include a bag but it costs more money so it might be cheaper to buy your bag. 
• Customer Service – The product comes with a one-year warranty. Some customers found that if an accessory broke within one year the replacement process was stressful due to poor customer service. 
• Buttons – The buttons on the control panel are not backlit which could be an issue during nighttime pumping 
• Display – The LED display is great but it is very bright which could cause problems whilst nighttime pumping

All About Medela In Style Pump

The Medela Pump In Style is a double-sided electric breast pump. It was developed by Dr. Daniela Zini and her husband Dr. Robert Zini.

It was first introduced in 2008 and since then it has quickly become one of the most widely used breast pumps on the market today.

The Medela Pump In Style is made up of four different parts: the breast shield, the milk collection bottle, the electric motor, and the milk storage bottle.

The breast shield is the part of the breast pump that sits on top of the breast and collects milk when you are expressing milk from the breasts.

The breast shield can be removed easily so that you can change the size of the nipple hole. 

The milk collection bottle is where all the milk collected from the breast shield goes.

It is attached to the breast shield and holds approximately 1/3 of a cup of milk at a time. 

The milk collection bottle is removable so that you can empty it whenever you want.

The electric motor is located underneath the milk collection bottle. It works together with the breast shield to help move the milk through the tubing.

The electric motor is powered by batteries which means that you have to charge the batteries before using the breast pump.

The last component of the Medela Pump In Style breast pump is the milk storage bottle.

This is where all the milk stored from the breast shield and the milk collection bottle goes.

The milk storage bottle is connected to the breast shield and the electric motor via tubes. The milk storage bottle can hold about 4 cups of milk.

Pros

• Reliable – this pump will last you a very long time, and it can be used for hours of pumping daily with no issues
• Large Capacity – stores up to 4 oz of milk at once
• Added extras – this pump comes with a few things to make pumping easier. These include a bottle stand, ice pack bag, and adjustable cooler 

Cons

• No display – so it is harder to see what settings you have selected

Ameda Breast Pump vs Medela

Now you’ve got a better understanding of these breast pumps individually, let’s compare some of the key product features.

Closed System 

Both the Ameda Mya Joy and Medela in style pumps are closed systems.

This prevents condensation within the tubes and also avoids the potential of milk entering the tubes, a key benefit when doing your best to avoid condensation or mold build-up within the tubes.

It also makes both systems easy to clean.

Power Source

Both the Medela and the Ameda are supplied with an AC power adaptor, which enables you to plug in your pump and instantly begin pumping.

Both pumps are powered by a rechargeable battery. The Ameda is powered by four AA batteries, but the Medela is powered by eight AA batteries.

While the battery pack is quite handy in an emergency, none of these devices has an extremely long battery life.

We recommend that you also get a car charger for the various brands, which are sold separately.

While this is an added cost, it means that you can charge and use these pumps on the go, which is very convenient. 

Suction Power

When it comes to suction strength, the Medela Pump In Style is the winner.

The Medela pump in style has a suction maximum strength of 270 mmHg while the Ameda Joy has a maximum suction strength of 250 mmHg.

There are also a few other benefits to using the Medela over the Ameda it terms of suction including their ‘Let down’ feature, which simplifies the process of starting the pump.

It is also able to automatically adjust the speed of the pump.

Additionally, the Medela features a variety of suction speed settings that must be adjusted manually.

Noise

Some breast pumps are quieter than others, and whilst this may not seem a big issue, if you have just put your baby down to sleep, the last thing you would want is a super loud breast pump disturbing their, and your rest. 

While the Ameda is somewhat louder than the Medela, we believe that both of these breast pumps are as discreet as possible.

While that is all good, the Ameda does have a very irritating feature. Through every suction cycle, this machine makes a beeping sound.

Though not loud, it is certainly annoying rough to disturb the peace  

If noise is a big deciding factor for you, you should go with the Medela pumps. 

Single Vs Double Pumping

Both the Medela and Ameda breast pumps may be used independently or in tandem, which is fairly convenient.

Numerous mothers breastfeed on one side while pumping on the other, so this may feel more natural to you. Both are equipped with a hands-free pumping bra.

Price

Both pumps are very similar in terms of pricing however if budget is your main concern then the Ameda is the cheaper option.

Support

Where the Medela shines is in terms of their Medela Family app.

The Medela Family app is designed to help mother easily track important stats for pregnancy, baby, and breastfeeding. It also provides you tips and support to help you meet your goals.

The Ameda brand does not have an app.

Final Thoughts on Medela Pump In Style vs Ameda Mya

Ameda and Medela are both high-quality breast pumps brands. Both products are constructed to meet the special demands of mothers in terms of durability and weight.

Which one would we choose?

If we had to choose we would go with the Medela Pump in Style for it’s higher suction power and supportive app.

We hope this guide on Ameda Mya vs Medela in style has helped you decide which pump will best suit your needs.

And if you’re looking for more great guides, make sure to check out these guides on best mini fridge for breast milk, best bottles for breastfed babies, and Medela Freestyle Flex review!