Motif Luna Vs Medela Pump In Style

Are you trying to decide between Motif Luna vs Medela Pump In Style?

Then let us help you decide which is best for you and your baby: Medela Pump In Style vs Motif Luna!

If you are interested in breast pumping then you will be surprised at how many different products there are on the market.

There are so many different types of breast pumps and lots of companies promise that their products will be able to help make your life easier. 

As a mother, breast pumping can be useful. However, it can also be time-consuming and uncomfortable.

If you have the right breast pump, you can speed up the process of expressing milk and minimize the discomfort to make it a much better experience. 

But which breast pump should you buy?

To make your decision easier, we have compared two of the best-selling breast pumps on the market – Motif Luna breast pump vs Medela.

If you want to know more about the features, pros, and cons of these two products and which one is going to be best, then keep reading. 

And if you love this Motif Luna breast pump vs Medela Pump In Style breast pump comparisons guide, make sure to check out our guides on Motif Luna vs Spectra S2, Motif Luna vs Spectra S1, and Medela Freestyle vs Pump In Style. Or even our Motif Duo Vs Motif Luna review!

This post contains affiliate links. See our full disclosure here

Motif Luna Vs Medela Pump In Style

Let’s dive in and take a look how the Motif breast pump vs Medela breast pump compare.

All About Motif Luna Breast Pump

The Motif Luna is an electric breast pump. It has been designed by Dr. Lori Greiner, who is a well-known American doctor and television personality.

The Motif Luna was first released in 2006 and since then it has become one of the most popular breast pumps available on the market.

This breast pump comes with three attachments: the suction cup, the milk storage bottle, and the double electric motor.

The suction cup attachment allows you to attach the breast pump to any flat surface such as a table or countertop. 

The milk storage bottle is attached to the suction cup and helps collect and store expressed milk for later use.

The double electric motor attaches to the bottom of the milk storage bottle and provides the power needed to express milk from the breasts.

The Motif Luna comes with a rechargeable battery pack that needs to be charged before using the product.

The motor is very powerful so you will be pleased with the level of suction it will provide. 

The Motif Luna has several advantages over other breast pumps on the market.

One of the main benefits of this breast pump is that it does not require any special skills to operate. 

All you need to do is plug the breast pump into an electrical outlet and press start.

Once started, the breast pump will automatically begin working without any further input from you.

Another advantage of the Motif Luna is that it is very easy to clean.

When you are finished using the breast pump, simply detach the suction cup and remove the milk storage bottle.

Then wash them both thoroughly under running water. 

Another great feature of the Motif Luna breast pump is that it is quiet.

When you are using the breast pump, you won’t hear anything coming out of the breast pump.

This makes it ideal if you are trying to get some sleep while feeding your baby. 

Pros

• Large capacity – stores up to 4 oz of milk at once
• Comfortable design
• Easy to use

Cons

• Not cordless
• Uses tubing

You can learn more in our full Motif Luna breast pump review!

All About Medela Pump In Style

The Medela Pump In Style is a double-sided electric breast pump. It was developed by Dr. Daniela Zini and her husband Dr. Robert Zini.

It was first introduced in 2008 and since then it has quickly become one of the most widely used breast pumps on the market today.

The Medela Pump In Style is made up of four different parts: the breast shield, the milk collection bottle, the electric motor, and the milk storage bottle.

The breast shield is the part of the breast pump that sits on top of the breast and collects milk when you are expressing milk from the breasts.

The breast shield can be removed easily so that you can change the size of the nipple hole. 

The milk collection bottle is where all the milk collected from the breast shield goes.

It is attached to the breast shield and holds approximately 1/3 of a cup of milk at a time. 

The milk collection bottle is removable so that you can empty it whenever you want.

The electric motor is located underneath the milk collection bottle. It works together with the breast shield to help move the milk through the tubing.

The electric motor is powered by batteries which means that you have to charge the batteries before using the breast pump.

The last component of the Medela Pump In Style breast pump is the milk storage bottle.

This is where all the milk stored from the breast shield and the milk collection bottle goes.

The milk storage bottle is connected to the breast shield and the electric motor via tubes. The milk storage bottle can hold about 4 cups of milk.

Pros

• Large capacity – stores up to 4 oz of milk at once
• Comfortable design
• Easy to use

Cons

• No display
• Not cordless
• Uses tubing

Medela Pump In Style vs Motif Luna

Both the Motif Luna and Medela Pump In Style are double-sided electric breast pumps. Both machines can produce high-quality milk and come with a variety of accessories.

However, there are quite a few similarities and differences between Medela Pump In Style with maxflow vs Motif Luna as we discuss below:

Similarities Between The Two Breast Pumps

Settings 

Both pumps have two suction settings which are designed to mimic a nursing baby to encourage milk expression. 

Tubing 

Both pumps collect the milk from the breast and transfer it to the storage bottle via tubing. You will need to make sure that the tubing is cleaned thoroughly after each use. 

Auto Shut Off 

Both breast pumps have an auto shut-off feature which means they will turn off after 30 minutes. This means you can safely take a nap while you are pumping. 

Dual Sided 

Both of these breast pumps are double-sided but can be used as single-sided when necessary. This means that you can express milk while you are breastfeeding. 

Storage Bag

Both products come with a storage bag included which is ideal for transporting the breast pump. 

Price 

These products are very similar in price. Considering their performance, they are both good value for money for their price bracket. 

Main Differences Between The Two Breast Pumps

Display 

The Motif Luna has a back-lit LCD display which makes it very easy to use at night or in a dark room.

The Medela Pump In Style doesn’t have any kind of display- only simple dials to control the suction settings. 

Noise 

The Motif Luna is much quieter than the Medela Pump In Style which makes it better for nighttime pumping as it won’t wake up your baby. 

Accessories 

Whilst both pumps come with breast shields and a storage bag, the Motif Luna also comes with a cleaning brush which makes it easier to wash the pump.

Shape 

The Medela pump is shaped like most other breast pumps. The Motif Luna has a unique moon shape which is where it gets its name from.

This is designed to feel comfortable against the breast and to be more comfortable to hold. 

Which Is Better – The Motif Luna Or The Medela Pump In Style?

Now that you know more about each product, it is time to decide which one is best.

There are many factors that you should consider when making this decision.

Both products are approximately the same price so your budget cannot be a deciding factor. 

These two products are very similar in terms of design and performance.

They are both double-sided electric breast pumps that can be used as single-sided when needed.

They are both plugged into power supplies which means they are not cordless.

They both use tubing to transport the milk from breast to bottle, which means they will both be fiddly to clean. 

Neither of these breast pumps is entirely hands-free. They both have two suction settings that imitate the stages of a natural breastfeeding cycle.

They both turn off automatically after thirty minutes for your safety. So how can you choose between them?

Whilst they are both great products, the Motif Luna seems to be the better choice.

There are only a few differences between the two products, but these differences give the Motif Luna this advantage. 

The Motif Luna is a quieter breast pump. This is important if you are using the breast pump while you are breastfeeding, as it will keep your baby relaxed.

It also means you can express milk while your baby is sleeping in the same room as you, or while your partner is sleeping. 

The display on the Motif Luna is also a lot better than the Medela pump.

It is very easy to see the Motif Luna pump display at night, but you would have to use a lamp to see the control dials on the Medela pump in a dark room. 

With the Motif Luna, you also get the benefit of the moon shape for additional comfort. 

FAQs on Motif vs Medela

Final Thoughts on Motif Luna Breast Pump vs Medela

Both of these breast pumps are very popular with women and offer fantastic performance.

You will be able to achieve a comfortable breast pumping experience and you can express milk efficiently with either one of these breast pumps.

However, as they are both a similar price then the Motif Luna is the best option as it has slightly more to offer. 

We hope this guide on Motif vs Medela has helped you decide which pump will best suit your needs.

And if you’re looking for more great guides, make sure to check out these guides on Haakaa breast pump review, best mini fridge for breast milk, and best bottles for breastfed babies.