Ameda Mya Vs Spectra S2

Are you trying to decide between Ameda Mya vs Spectra s2 electric breast pumps?

Then let us help you decide which electric pump best for you and your baby: Ameda Mya Joy vs Spectra s2!

If you are expecting a baby or you have a newborn then there is a good chance that you are considering buying a breast pump. Breast pumps are really useful as they allow you to express your breast milk into bottles.

But, when it comes to choosing a breast pump there is a wide range of products available on the market which can make it hard to know which one is the best choice for you. Especially, as breast pumps vary in style and type and of course in price as well.

So we have compared two well known pumps Spectra s2 vs Ameda Mya to help you find out which pump will be best for you!

Both brands offer quality pumps that will help you express your milk, but they do it in different ways.

So, in this useful guide we compare the two products to help you decide which one will be best for you. Keep reading to find out more about their features, pros, and cons.

And if you love this Ameda vs Spectra breast pump comparisons guide, make sure to check out our guides on Spectra S2 Plus breast pump review, Elvie vs Spectra, and Spectra S1 vs S2 vs S9. Or even our Ameda Mya Breast Pump reviews.

This post contains affiliate links. See our full disclosure here

Ameda Mya vs Spectra s2

Let’s dive in an look at both brands and their breast pumps.

All About The Ameda Mya 

The Ameda Mya is known for being small and lightweight whilst still offering hospital-grade suction. Not only is the motor powerful, but it is also very quiet.

The motor runs at 45db which means that it won’t wake up your sleeping baby- perfect for nighttime pumping!

The only issue with nighttime pumping is that the buttons are not backlit which could make them difficult to see in the dark, yet the LED screen is very bright which could be a problem. 

It has an ergonomic design that feels very comfortable. It weighs just half a pound so you will be impressed at how light it is.

It is also small enough to be transported easily, making it simple to take on the go with you.

The battery is rechargeable and can run for two hours, so you can easily take the breast pump with you on a day out and be able to use it several times without needing a power source.

The pump is very easy to assemble. Once you are familiar with the set up you will be able to set it up in less than 30 seconds.

The variable rate control dial allows you to easily adjust the speed and direction of the vacuum.

The pump has 5 different massage modes to encourage the milk flow and 10 expression modes to extract the milk.

This is designed to imitate the nursing habits of a baby whilst enabling you to customize the pumping cycle to suit your body. The Ameda Mya has a pumping capacity of 280mmHG and a flow rate of up to 15ml per hour. 

The Ameda Mya pump comes with various bottles and removable cups. It can hold 8 ounces of milk at any one time which should be plenty for most mothers. The pump has a closed system which makes it very easy to clean. 

All you need to do is disassemble the pump and wash any parts that come into contact with the milk in warm water and soap. Some parts of the pump are dishwasher safe which makes the cleaning process even easier. 

Pros

• Size – The breast pump is small and lightweight which makes it comfortable to use and easy to transport. 
• Power – Despite the small size, this breast pump has a powerful motor that produces an efficient flow rate. 
• Noise – The motor runs quietly which is ideal for nighttime pumping and discreet pumping. 
• Simple – The pump is easy to assemble and disassemble and is very simple to use 
• Cleaning – The pump has a closed system which makes it easy to clean, and some of the parts are dishwasher safe 

Cons

• Storage – The Ameda Mya does not come with a storage bag to keep all of the accessories in. Some retailers offer a bundle that does include a bag but it costs more money so it might be cheaper to buy your bag. 
• Customer Service – The product comes with a one-year warranty. Some customers found that if an accessory broke within one year the replacement process was stressful due to poor customer service. 
• Buttons – The buttons on the control panel are not backlit which could be an issue during nighttime pumping 
• Display – The LED display is great but it is very bright which could cause problems whilst nighttime pumping

All About The Spectra S2

The Spectra S2 is a powerful breast pump that can be used single-sided or double-sided. It is made from medical-grade silicone which is hypoallergenic and non-porous.

The pump comes with two bottles, two breast shields, two suction tubes, and a power adaptor. 

Like the Ameda Mya, this pump offers hospital-grade suction. The massage mode can be used to encourage the milk and the variable expression mode allows you to adjust the speed and suction to find the best setting for your milk flow.

There is also a letdown setting that shuts off automatically after 30 minutes. 

You will be surprised at how quiet the motor is. This makes it ideal to pump discreetly in a public place or to pump at night time without waking your baby.

The Spectra S2 also has a night light which makes it easy for you to see what you are doing during a nighttime pumping session. 

This breast pump has a closed system which makes it very easy to keep the pump clean and hygienic after each use. One of the downsides to the Spectra S2 is that there is no rechargeable battery.

The pump has to be plugged into a power source at all times which makes it difficult to use on the go.

The LED display screen is really useful and shows you how long you have been pumping. You are also able to set a timer on the pump so you know when to stop.

This pump is known for having a strong motor which is ideal for mothers who are struggling with low milk supply. The suction strength goes up to 270mmHG.

Despite the powerful motor, it is still comfortable and gentle to use. It has silicone cushioning which feels nice against your skin.

One of the most useful features of the Spectra S2 is that once you have adjusted the settings and found a combination of speed and suction that works for you, the setting can be saved so you can access it easily next time.

You can save up to three different settings. 

Pros

• Suction – This breast pump offers hospital-grade suction with variable settings 
• Memory – You can save up to three of your favorite settings to make each pumping session easier 
• Night light – The pump has a night light which makes nighttime pumping much easier
• Display – The LED display screen features a timer option and tells you how long you have been pumping for 
• Noise – The motor is nice and quiet so you can use it discreetly 
• Closed system – This breast pump has a closed system which is ideal for keeping the pump clean

Cons

• Power – This breast pump needs to be plugged into a power source at all times which can make it difficult to pump on the go 

Similarities and Differences Between Ameda Mya Joy vs Spectra s2

Now that you know more about each product, which breast pump is the best choice? Now that we have an overview of both pumps, let’s look more closely at their similarities and differences.

• They both offer hospital-grade suction, though the Ameda Mya might be slightly more powerful. 
• Both pumps have a closed system which is easy to clean
• The motor on each breast pump runs quietly 
• Both pumps have variable settings which allow you to customize the suction and speed to suit your needs
• Each pump has an LED display screen
• The Ameda Mya is much smaller and lighter than the Spectra S2, making it easy to transport
• The Ameda Mya has a rechargeable battery and can be used on the go, whereas the Spectra S2 must be plugged into a power source at all times 
• The Spectra S2 has a night light which is useful for nighttime pumping 
• The Spectra S2 has an automatic shut off feature after 30 minutes

Final Thoughts on Spectra s2 vs Ameda Mya

These breast pumps are very similar in price and offer a very similar level of performance. They share the same basic features and would both make an excellent choice.

If having a lightweight, portable breast pump which can be used on the go is important to you then choose the Ameda Mya.

If you would be willing to sacrifice portability for a few extra features then choose the Spectra S2. 

And if you’re looking for more great guides, make sure to check out these guides on best mini fridge for breast milk, how to power pump with Spectra S2 and best pumping bra for Spectra. Or even our review on Ameda Breast Pump Vs Medela Pump In Style.