Ubbi Vs Diaper Genie

Trying to choose between Ubbi vs Diaper Genie for disposing of your baby’s dirty diapers?

Then let us help you decide which is the best diaper pail for you: Ubbi diaper pail vs Diaper Genie!

Both these diaper pails claim they can keep bad smells away, and improve changing time. But how well do they perform?

No one wants to put dirty diapers in the regular trash can.

Not only is this unhygienic, but it can create a terrible smell!

Instead, you need a diaper pail, specifically designed for locking used diapers (and their smells) away.

Ubbi and Diaper Genie are diaper pails that are very popular with parents, but which is right for you?

In this Ubbi steel diaper pail vs Diaper Genie review, we have compared both diaper pails compare, focusing on usability, odor prevention, price, and more so you can find the perfect diaper pail for you and your little one!

And if you love this guide on what’s the difference between Diaper Genie and Ubbi diaper pails, then check out these guides on effective diaper pail deodorizer ideas and best diaper pail alternatives. Or even our reviews on Ubbi vs Munchkin diaper pail, Dekor vs Diaper Genie, and Diaper Genie Elite vs Complete.

This post contains affiliate links. See our full disclosure here

Ubbi Vs Diaper Genie

Let’s get started with a close look at both the Ubbi and the Diaper Genie!

All About Ubbi 

The Ubbi diaper pail is an award winning design, a sleek steel trash can with an airtight lock that aims to keep odors hidden.

The innovative Ubbi uses an impressive locking design to seal in diapers, with a child safety lock to prevent curious hands from causing disasters.

Finished with a powder coating, the Ubbi is easy to clean, and the variety of color choices should appeal to nursery designers. 

The Ubbi uses a simple method to keep bad smells in, letting the build and materials do most of the work.

Pros

• The steel build naturally resists absorbing odors.
• An excellent child lock keeps used diapers safely stored away.
• Various attractive color options.
• The Ubbi can be used with standard garbage bags.

Cons

• You have to open the lid by hand, as there’s no foot pedal.
• When you open the lid, bad smells can come through.

All About Diaper Genie

When the Diaper Genie first came on the market, it really did seem like magic for parents.

The Diaper Genie takes a used diaper and locks it away behind a double airtight clamp, preventing bad smells from filling the nursery.

Easy to use with a foot pedal opening, the Diaper Genie is a hands-free option for busy parents.

A carbon-filter captures errant bad smells, while the double airtight clamps stop odors from leaking in the first place.

Diaper Genie offers both the Complete and the Expressions.

The Expressions range is an excellent budget buy, but the Complete really is (pardon the pun) the complete package.

For this review, we’ll be focusing on the Complete.

Pros

• The foot pedal allows for hands-free diaper disposal.
• A carbon filter deodorizes, adding even more protection.
• When the lid opens, smells are still trapped in.

Cons

• To make the most of the pail, you have to purchase the Diaper Genie branded liners.
• Despite the claimed capacity of 270 diapers, the Diaper Genie fills up quickly.

Similarities And Differences Between Ubbi Vs Diaper Genie

Both the Ubbi and the Diaper Genie are incredibly popular with parents, and have won awards for excellence.

In terms of overall design, there are quite a few similarities, but the differences between these diaper pails will determine which brand is right for you.

So, let’s explore these similarities and differences in detail.

Bad Odor Banishment

Dirty diapers have an unforgettable smell, and it’s not the kind of scent you want in your lovely nursery.

Both the Ubbi and the Diaper Genie claim to keep diaper smells locked inside the pail, but how do they actually perform?

Diaper Genie controls odor using Double Air-Tite clamps and a multi-layer refill bag.

A clever locking mechanism keeps the stink in even when you open the lid: simply drop your diaper in the pail, and it falls into the bag when the lid closes.

With a carbon filter acting as a deodorizer, the Diaper Genie remains (almost) completely odor free!

The Ubbi doesn’t use filters or bags to prevent smells from leaking.

Instead, it relies on the construction of the pail.

The Ubbi is made with steel, unlike the plastic Diaper Genie, which doesn’t absorb smells.

It also has an airtight seal, so when the Ubbi is closed, the smells are locked in. 

For the most part, both the Ubbi and the Diaper Genie banish bad odors.

However, we think the Diaper Genie does a better job.

When the Ubbi is opened up, smells have a chance to escape.

Size

The Diaper Genie claims that the refill bags can hold up to 270 newborn diapers, but this is not quite true in theory.

The general consensus is that the Diaper Genie can hold 30 to 40 newborn diapers.

The Ubbi claims to hold 55 newborn diapers, and users seem to agree that is accurate. 

In terms of size, Ubbi is the winner.

You might get a few more days out of the Ubbi before you have to empty it, but the Diaper Genie isn’t far behind.

Materials

The Ubbi is made from steel, and was the very first steel diaper pail.

Steel isn’t porous, so it doesn’t absorb smells.

The steel Ubbi is lightweight but durable, and relatively easy to clean.

The only downside is it has to be wiped with a dry cloth.

If moisture gets trapped inside the Ubbi, it can start to rust.

The Diaper Genie is made from plastic. This is very easy to clean, and you can wipe it thoroughly with a damp cloth.

But plastic can absorb smells, and you might notice a slight odor to the Diaper Genie if you stop using the refills and right bags. 

Durability

Your little one is likely to be in diapers for at least two years, so you need a diaper pail that can withstand repeated usage.

Even a slight crack can destroy the smell-busting properties. 

Thankfully, both the Ubbi and the Diaper Genie have an incredibly durable design.

You can use either diaper pail from the first diaper all the way through to the last change.

Opening Mechanism

The Diaper Genie uses a foot pedal to open the lid.

Press the pedal, dispose of the diaper, and close the lid.

It’s easier on the back (there’s no bending down), and you can operate the Diaper Genie one-handed.

So, you can hold onto a wiggly baby, and throw away their diaper, with no stress. 

The Ubbi, on the other hand, uses a sliding mechanism that has to be operated by hand.

The slide mechanism does ensure minimal air disturbance, but the lack of hands-free opening is a major downside.

If you’ve got a fussy baby after a diaper change, you’ll need to put your little one down, throw away the diaper, and then pick them up again.

You also have to bend down to use the Ubbi, which can cause backache.

Child Locks

There are some issues to the Ubbi opening mechanism, but it also has a major benefit: the Ubbi includes a childproof lock. 

Kids are endlessly curious, even when it comes to bad smells!

And if they get into the diaper pail, that can cause disaster.

With the Ubbi child lock, you can ensure the diaper pail, and the diapers, stay locked up.

While the Diaper Genie isn’t exactly easy to break into, it doesn’t have a child lock.

Something to keep in mind, particularly if you have toddlers.

Color And Design

For a diaper pail, both the Ubbi and the Diaper Genie look pretty good!

The designs are sleek and simple, and won’t stand out in the nursery.

The Diaper Genie comes with a gloss finish and limited color options.

It’s nice enough, but not exactly inspiring.

But if it’s style you’re after, the Ubbi comes out on top.

The powder finish looks good and is easy to clean, and there are numerous color options.

No matter what your nursery looks like, the Ubbi has a style to match.

Liner Brands

If you want to make the most of the Diaper Genie, then you need to use the Diaper Genie branded refill bags.

These are specifically designed to fit into the Diaper Genie, and use a multi-layer film to lock in bad smells and prevent bacteria growth.

They’re pretty great, but they’re also expensive. 

You can potentially use the Diaper Genie with other, non-branded garbage bags, but they won’t fit the pail quite so well. 

But the Ubbi can be used with their branded disposable bags or any generic garbage bag. 

Price

The Diaper Genie itself is cheaper than the Ubbi.

However, as the Diaper Genie really should be used with the Diaper Genie liners, and it requires refills to really banish the scent, that saving fades the more you use the pail. 

Final Thoughts On Ubbi Vs Diaper Genie

Both the Ubbi and the Diaper Genie are cleverly designed diaper pails that can lock away bad odors for more pleasant diaper changes. 

Overall, we prefer the performance of the Diaper Genie.

It does an excellent job at keeping bad smells away, and the foot pedal is incredibly convenient. 

But the Ubbi has some strong points, such as the stainless steel build, and the color range.

We think the Ubbi and the Diaper Genie can both deliver a high quality performance, and stop the nursery smelling of dirty diapers!

We hope this guide will help you banish bad smells with either the Ubbi or the Diaper Genie!

And if you like this guide on Ubbi pail vs Diaper Genie, then you’ll love our other diapering guides on Huggies Snug And Dry vs Little Movers, how long can I leave a wet diaper on, Hello Bello vs Pampers, and best diapers to prevent blowouts.