Dekor Vs Diaper Genie

Trying to choose between Dekor vs Diaper Genie for disposing of your baby’s dirty diapers?

Then let us help you decide which is the best diaper pail for you: Dekor Diaper Pail vs Diaper Genie!

When you’re putting together a nursery, diaper pails are hardly the most exciting things to consider.

But as fun as it is to choose toys and outfits and adorable tiny furniture, the diaper pail is one of the most important things on the baby registry!

When you hear the words “diaper pail”, there’s a good chance that Diaper Genie comes to mind.

This brand is one of the best known in the business, thanks to innovative and durable designs. But Dekor is gaining popularity, due to its easy use and excellent versatility.

In this Diaper Genie vs Dekor review, we have compared both diaper pails compare, focusing on usability, odor prevention, price, and more so you can find the perfect diaper pail for you and your little one!

And if you love this guide on what’s the difference between Dekor and Diaper Genie, then check out these guides on effective diaper pail deodorizer ideas and best diaper pail alternatives. Or even our reviews on Dekor Classic vs PlusDiaper Genie vs Munchkin and Ubbi vs Diaper Genie.

This post contains affiliate links. See our full disclosure here

Our Top Pick
Diaper Genie Complete Diaper Pail
$66.10

The diaper Genie is a much loved diaper pail among parents, and for good reason!

It is easy to use with is foot pedal for easy, hygienic and hands-free opening. It is also tall so you don't need to bend down to use it.

But best of all, the Complete Pail features Double Air-Tite clamps that work with the 7-layer diaper refill bags and carbon filter to add a layer of double odor protection.


12/08/2022 09:20 pm GMT

Dekor Vs Diaper Genie

In this section, we’ll take a look at what Dekor and Diaper Genie are all about.

All About Dekor

Dekor is a brand that recognizes parents are after convenience! When it comes to diaper changes, we all want to keep it as fuss free as possible.

That’s why Dekor uses a Step, Drop, and Done system. Simply step on the foot pedal, drop in the diaper, and you are done!

The Dekor diaper pail range is simple, offering the same convenient features in different sizes.

Built from ABS plastic, the Dekor diaper pail shouldn’t absorb odors, but should stand up to regular use.

And with a trapdoor opening, odors stay locked in when the pail isn’t in use. Although, prepare for a bit of a whiff whenever you open the lid!

Parents love the versatility of the Dekor Plus.

Thanks to a larger opening, the Plus can be used for cloth diapers. It’s particularly effective in conjunction with the Dekor reusable liners!

Parents who prefer cloth diapers can enjoy the odor-limiting benefits of a Dekor pail.

Pros

  • The Step, Drop, and Done system offers hands-free disposal.
  • Built from ABS plastic, which doesn’t absorb odors.
  • The trapdoor system limits the amount of air that escapes.
  • The Dekor Plus can be used with cloth and disposable diapers.
  • Dekor branded liners reduce waste, and mask odors.

Cons

  • When the trapdoor opens, there’s a sudden expulsion of bad smells.
  • The fittings are less durable than brands at similar price points.

All About Diaper Genie

For many of us, Diaper Genie is the first brand that comes to mind when we think of diaper pails. 

Diaper Genie have adapted and expanded their designs throughout the years, to match the changing needs of modern parents.

This is a brand known for innovation, and for inventing new ways to deal with common problems.

Designs such as the Diaper Genie Complete offer hands-free disposal in a sleek design, while the Diaper Genie Expression locks in odors with a push-through opening.

Another reason for the Diaper Genie popularity is affordability.

The base designs are relatively inexpensive, and incredibly durable. One Diaper Genie can last for multiple children!

Pros

  • A well known brand with decades of popularity.
  • Innovative designs, including the Complete with hands-free operation.
  • Diaper Genie products have a sturdy build, and impressive durability.
  • The locking door mechanism keeps odors in the pail.
  • Diaper Genie refill bags use a multi-layer film to prevent germ transmission, and reduce odor.

Cons

  • It’s difficult to use cheaper, non-Diaper Genie branded liners in a Diaper Genie.
  • Not good for cloth diapers.
Our Top Pick
Diaper Genie Complete Diaper Pail
$66.10

The diaper Genie is a much loved diaper pail among parents, and for good reason!

It is easy to use with is foot pedal for easy, hygienic and hands-free opening. It is also tall so you don't need to bend down to use it.

But best of all, the Complete Pail features Double Air-Tite clamps that work with the 7-layer diaper refill bags and carbon filter to add a layer of double odor protection.


12/08/2022 09:20 pm GMT

Similarities And Differences Between Dekor and Diaper Genie

Dekor and Diaper Genie both aim to make changing time easier. In this section, we’ll take a look at their similarities and differences, to see how the brands compare.

Hands-Free Use

One of the major selling points of both Dekor and Diaper Genie is that they provide a hands-free method for disposing of diapers.

Diaper Genie Complete and Dekor pails use a foot pedal to open the lid. You then drop in your diaper, which should fall through without pushing, and close the lid.

All Dekor branded diaper pails are hands-free.

That’s the Classic, the Plus, and the Mini. No matter which Dekor pail you choose, you can avoid getting your hands (too) dirty.

The Diaper Genie Complete pail has a hands-free opening, but not the Expressions. The Expressions pail has a push button lid and a push-n-lock opening.

It can be used one-handed, but it is a messier system. 

Odor Control

Odor control is a crucial feature of any diaper pail, and both Diaper Genie and Dekor have included several odor-busting features.

First, both Diaper Genie and Dekor use locking doors to prevent odors from leaking through. Essentially, the doors only open when diapers are dropping.

As the lid is closed most of the time, bad smells stay shut in.

The Diaper Genie Complete uses a double locking system to achieve this. When you open the lid of the Diaper Genie, an opening inside the pail closes.

So, you drop the diaper part way in, and close the lid. The second door then unlocks, dropping the diaper into the bag.

The Dekor uses a spring-loaded trapdoor. It falls open when a diaper drops through, and then closes automatically.

Both designs are good, and they do minimize odor leaks. However, the Dekor has a wider opening, so the whiff of bad air is worse. 

Diaper Genie has also included a carbon filter with the Complete design. This sits in the lid, and neutralizes odors that start escaping. 

Liners

Diaper Genie pails are designed to be used with Diaper Genie liners. These bags fit into the closed opening easily, and can then be pulled through into the pail.

Diaper Genie refill bags offer impressive odor control and a built-in microbial. However, they are expensive.

Dekor diaper pails are also intended to be used with Dekor branded refills.

The Dekor refills are continuous and not pre-sized, with a powder scent used to mask the odor. They fit into the Dekor pails, but like Diaper Genie refills, are pretty expensive.

However, it’s easy to use other branded bags with Dekor, including generic trash bags.

They might not have the convenient features of the Dekor bags, but they can save you money.

It’s much harder to fit a generic trash bag into a Diaper Genie pail.

It’s not impossible, but expect a lot of fiddly work (and maybe the help of a video tutorial). And some brands don’t fit at all.

12/08/2022 09:20 pm GMT
12/09/2022 01:36 am GMT

Child Lock

Dekor diaper pails include hidden child locks, which keep curious fingers out of the diaper pail (and dirty diapers in).

Diaper Genie brand pails do not include child locks. They’re fairly sturdy, but kids love to play, and those swinging doors present a lot of opportunity!

Disposable Vs Cloth Diapers

The Diaper Genie is designed to be used with disposable diapers. The narrow opening reduces odor escape, and allows tightly folded diapers to drop into the pail below. 

If you wanted to use the Diaper Genie Complete with a cloth diaper, you could, but it might not be pretty!

The opening is narrow, and bulky cloth diapers could get stuck. And the Diaper Genie is designed to be used with disposable liners.

You’d have to remove the liner, empty the diapers into the washer, and then throw the liner in the trash.

The Dekor Plus, on the other hand, is adept at handling cloth diapers.

It has a large opening, so the diapers can fall into the pail without pushing, and the wider body can hold more bulk.

Dekor also sells cloth diaper refill liners, designed for the Plus, which have a waterproof coating and can be machine washed. 

Price

Overall, there is very little price difference between Diaper Genie and Dekor. These brands both offer mid-range diaper pails.

They’re affordable, but not inexpensive. Both brands also sell smaller, more cost effective diaper pails, such as the Dekor Mini, and the Diaper Genie Expressions.

The real price difference comes when we consider the add ons. Both brands offer their own refill liners, which are specially formulated for the pails.

Dekor liners and Diaper Genie liners are both similarly priced.

However, it’s easy to use generic trash bags with Dekor pails, which can potentially save you money.

Although some generic liners do fit in the Diaper Genie, it’s harder to find a cheaper liner that fits perfectly.

The Diaper Genie Complete also includes a carbon filter in the lid. This is excellent at absorbing odor, but it is another expense.

The carbon filter needs to be replaced roughly once every month, but you can purchase cheaper, generic alternatives.

Our Top Pick
Diaper Genie Complete Diaper Pail
$66.10

The diaper Genie is a much loved diaper pail among parents, and for good reason!

It is easy to use with is foot pedal for easy, hygienic and hands-free opening. It is also tall so you don't need to bend down to use it.

But best of all, the Complete Pail features Double Air-Tite clamps that work with the 7-layer diaper refill bags and carbon filter to add a layer of double odor protection.


12/08/2022 09:20 pm GMT

Final Thoughts On Diaper Genie vs Dekor

There are a lot of advantages to Dekor branded diaper pails. The hands-free system is incredibly convenient, and the larger Plus can be used for cloth diapers.

Dekor pails are easy to use with other branded liners, and the child lock prevents some potential disasters.

But, overall, we prefer Diaper Genie!

The odor control is superior, because the double lock system prevents a sudden blast of bad air every time you throw away a diaper!

Overall, these are two excellent diaper pails brands, and they add ease to changing time.

We hope this review has helped you find the diaper pail that’s right for you!

And if you like this guide on Diaper Dekor vs Diaper Genie, then you’ll love our other diapering guides on best diapers for sensitive skinbest diapers to prevent blowouts, Diaper Genie Elite vs Complete, and trash can vs diaper pail.

Our Top Pick
Diaper Genie Complete Diaper Pail
$66.10

The diaper Genie is a much loved diaper pail among parents, and for good reason!

It is easy to use with is foot pedal for easy, hygienic and hands-free opening. It is also tall so you don't need to bend down to use it.

But best of all, the Complete Pail features Double Air-Tite clamps that work with the 7-layer diaper refill bags and carbon filter to add a layer of double odor protection.


12/08/2022 09:20 pm GMT
dekor vs diaper genie