Elvie Vs Willow Breast Pump

Are you trying to decide between Elvie vs Willow electric breast pumps?

Then let us help you decide which electric pump best for you and your baby: Elvie vs Willow pump!

If you are breastfeeding and you want to try using a pump, then you have probably begun to research hands-free breast pumps. They are extremely useful and convenient for mothers.

A breast pump allows you to express breast milk to feed to your baby at a later date, which means that any member of the family can feed the baby.

It also means that you don’t have to breastfeed every time your baby gets hungry, which means that your day is less disrupted. 

Whilst breast-pumping can be very helpful for mothers, it also takes a lot of time and can feel like a hassle.

Mother’s often feel the need to remove themselves from the room to express their milk, causing them to feel lonely or left out.

This is why discreet, hands-free breast pumps are so useful. You can express your breast milk whilst still having your hands available to do something else. 

There are lots of different hands-free breast pumps available on the market, and you might find it difficult to narrow down your choice.

To make this decision easier for you we have reviewed two of the best breast pumps that are available to buy right now- Willow vs Elvie. 

Keep reading to find out about the features, pros, and cons of these products so you can decide which one is best for you.

And if you love this Willow vs Elvie pump comparisons guide, make sure to check out our guides on Elvie breast pump review, best bras for Willow pump, and best bra for Elvie pump. Or even our reviews on Elvie Stride vs Elvie Pump and Momcozy vs Elvie!

This post contains affiliate links. See our full disclosure here

Elvie Vs Willow

Let’s dive in an look at both brands and their breast pumps.

All About Elvie Breast Pump

The Elvie breast pump is a double-sided breast pump that slides into your nursing bra. It is a hands-free pump, which means you can use it while you are getting on with something else.

It is also cordless, which means you can walk around while you are pumping, making it even easier to multitask. The breast pump is charged up, then you assemble it and place it into your nursing bra. 

Each side of the breast pump is a single unit that houses the pump, the milk storage, and the breast shield.

This means that you don’t need to connect the pump to a separate milk storage container, giving you more freedom to move around and making the activity more discreet.

The noise made by the pump is quiet, which means that if you are pumping underneath your clothes then other people are unlikely to be able to hear it. 

One of the great features of the Elvie breast pump is the bra-strap extenders which are easily attached and removed when needed.

This means that you can attach the breast pump to your nursing bra, giving you peace of mind that it will remain in place while you are going about your day.

It also means you can take a nap while you are pumping and the breast pumps will stay put. 

It takes approximately 2 hours to fully charge the battery of your Elvie breast pump, and each charge will last for up to three hours.

The pump has Bluetooth connectivity which means that you can control the breast pump with an app on your smartphone.

The app will also keep track of how much milk you have expressed and the flow rate. It tracks each side of the pump separately, so you can see if one breast is producing more milk than the other. 

There are two main downsides to the Elvie breast pump. One is the lights on the display.

They are designed to make it easy for you to see when the pump is activated, but they make the whole pumping process much less discreet which is not ideal if you were hoping to do it in company without anyone noticing. 

The other drawback is that the pump is quite fiddly to clean. You have to make sure you clean the pump after each use and make sure it is completely dry before reusing it or putting it back on charge, but this can be quite a hassle. 

Overall, the Elvie breast pump is a great product for mothers who are looking for more freedom while they express their milk. 

Pros

• Capacity – Each side of the breast pump can hold up to 5 ounces of milk 
• Freedom – The breast pump is hands-free, cordless, and fits securely in your nursing bra to allow you the freedom to move around and multitask while you pump 
• Simple – The breast pump is easy to assemble and use 
• Bluetooth – The pump connects to your smartphone via Bluetooth which allows you to control the pump and monitor the milk flow 

Cons

• Maintenance – The pump is quite difficult to clean which can take up your time once you have finished expressing 
• Discretion – Whilst the pump is quiet, the lights on the display are easily visible even through clothing 

All About Willow Breast Pump

The Willow breast pump is also a hands-free, cordless, double-sided pump that fits neatly into a nursing bra. It is quiet and discreet, allowing you to express milk without feeling self-conscious or having to leave the room. 

One of the main differences between the Willow breast pump and the Elvie breast pump is that with the Willow, you can choose between using milk containers or milk bags.

Both the containers and the bags attach easily to the pump to form one unit, so there are no long tubes or external items for collecting the milk. 

However, the milk containers for the Willow cannot hold as much milk – 4 ounces for each side as opposed to 5, which could be an issue for mothers who can produce a lot of milk at one time.

The pump comes with the bags as standard but the containers have to be purchased separately which makes the Willow slightly more expensive. 

Some of the parts of the Willow are dishwasher safe which makes it easier to clean than the Elvie, but it is still quite fiddly.

Like Elvie, the Willow can be controlled using an app on your smartphone. From the app, you can switch between the 7 different levels of pumping to find out which suits you best. 

One of the best features of the Willow breast pump is that it is designed to work very well even when you are lying down. This is ideal for mothers who like to express milk whilst they are taking a nap.

The Willow pump is a little more discreet because it doesn’t have any lights on the display. 

Like the Elvie, the Willow is re-chargeable and it takes approximately 2 hours for it to reach its full charge. It comes with a one-year warranty so you can have peace of mind. 

Pros

• Choice – You can use a milk container or a milk bag depending on your preference 
• Cleaning – Some of the parts are dishwasher safe which makes it very easy to maintain 
• Discreet – The pump is quiet and there are no lights on the display which makes it very discreet if you want to use it in public or with company 
• Bluetooth – The pump connects to an app on your smartphone which makes it easy to control and monitor
• Secure – The pump will stay in place even while you are lying down, which makes it convenient for mothers who like to express themselves whilst they are sleeping. 

Cons

• Capacity – The pump has an overall capacity of 8 ounces compared to the Elvie which has 10 ounces. 
• Use – This pump is not as simple to use as the Elvie and takes a little more practice 
• Cost – The milk bags come with the pump but the milk containers do not which makes it a little more expensive overall

Willow vs Elvie: Which Pump Is Best?

Both of these products are very popular with breast-pumping mothers. They have similar features in that they are double-sided, cordless, and hands-free.

They both have a single-unit design which is discreet and easy to tuck into a nursing bra. 

Both pumps give you the freedom to move around while you are breast pumping or to lie down and take a nap.

Both pumps connect to an app on your smartphone for convenient control of the pump and as a way to monitor the milk flow.

Both pumps also have 7 different pumping levels to choose from that you can switch between.

The Willow is slightly better when it comes to discretion, as there are no lights on the display.

The Elvie has lights that can be seen through a layer of clothing, making it more challenging to use the pump when you are trying to be subtle. However, the Willow is a little more complicated to use. 

The Elvie is the leader of the two products in terms of milk capacity, as it can hold 10 ounces as opposed to 8. However, it is more fiddly to clean. 

Final Thoughts on Elvie vs Willow Pump

The Elvie breast pump and the Willow breast pump are both excellent choices.

But which one would we choose?

If we had to choose, we would choose the Elvie for it’s larger milk storage capacity and lower price. 

And if you’re looking for more great guides, make sure to check out these guides on best mini fridge for breast milk, Freemie vs Willow, and Elvie vs Spectra.