Spectra S9 Vs Spectra S2

Are you trying to decide between Spectra S9 vs Spectra S2?

Then let us help you decide which is best for you and your baby: Spectra 9 plus vs Spectra s2!

Anyone who has shopped around for a new breast pump has surely heard of the Spectra brand.

Spectra is well-known and loved by moms everywhere, as all of their products are very high-quality. 

Spectra has a number of breast pumps that are suitable for a range of mothers, but today we will be looking at some of their most popular products, the Spectra 9 Plus and Spectra S2.

In this review, we will compare the main features, pros, and cons of both to help you decide which one is the best breast pump for you. 

And if you love this Spectra 9 plus vs s2 plus breast pump comparison guide, make sure to check out our guides on best pumping bra for Spectra, how to power pump with Spectra s2, and Spectra S1 Vs S2 Vs S9.

This post contains affiliate links. See our full disclosure here

Spectra s9 vs Spectra s2

Let’s dive in and take a look how the Spectra 9 vs Spectra s2 compare.

All About Spectra 9 Plus

The Spectra 9 Plus is a dual electric pump that is both lightweight and portable, making it ideal to travel with.

Because it is more portable than the S2, its features are more geared toward making the best pump to use on the go.

This pump has a rechargeable battery with a long battery life that is already installed.

It has an LCD display and touch-button controls, which make it simple to regulate the power and speed of the motor. There is also a letdown mode provided. 

With fewer adjustment options than the S2, and with increasing engine speed, the suction strength of this model is lower as well. 

It is a closed-system pump, similar to the S2, with backflow protection measures built in. 

With all of its excellent features, it is one of the best breast pumps for working parents currently available on the market today.

Pros

• Small – this is the most compact breast pump that Spectra makes. It is very portable due to its lightweight and small size
• Rechargeable battery – this is also another factor that makes this battery very portable. As it does not need to be plugged into a wall, this product allows you to pump anywhere you want
• LED display – this screen shows you a variety of information, such as your suction level, battery indicator, and what mode you are in
• Closed-system – this type of pump is a lot more hygienic than open-system pumps as this completely prevents the change of mold or condensation from appearing in the tubes of the pump. This keeps your milk contamination-free

Cons

• Not suitable for heavy use – if you want to pump multiple times a day weekly, then this pump will not be able to keep up with your needs. If you only want to pump a few times a week, however, it will be fine for you
• Cannot adjust the speed – on this pump, the speed automatically adjusts as you go through the cycle. You may find this annoying or uncomfortable if it is too fast or slow

All About Spectra S2​

The Spectra S2 is one of the most popular hospital-grade twin electric breast pumps available on the market.

It offers a massage mode, as well as 12 various levels of strength for you to choose from. 

A rechargeable battery is not included with this pump, but it is almost identical in design to its sibling pump, the Spectra S1, which also has a rechargeable battery. 

The S2 may be used in either a single or double pump configuration, and all of the attachments are simply interchangeable.

It is a closed-system pump of hospital-grade quality that features backflow protection, an LCD display, and a nightlight for added convenience and safety.

It is one of the most effective pumps for those who have low milk production levels.

Pros

• Very quiet – you won’t have to worry about disturbing anyone around you when you use this pump. It is quiet enough that you can use it in the same room as your sleeping baby or partner without worrying about waking them up
• Low cost – compared to the 9, the S2 is a lot cheaper. It is also competitively priced compared to other pumps 
• Closed-system – like the 9, this is a closed system pump, which is the best kind to get
• Can double or single pump – if you want to breastfeed and pump at the same time then you can with the S2

Cons

• Not portable – to use this pup you must plug it into an electrical outlet, meaning that while you pump you are stuck in one spot
• Suction fluctuates – when using this pump on both breasts at once, you may notice that the suction drops a bit

Spectra 9 vs Spectra s2

Now that we have had an overview of both breast pumps, let’s take a closer look at some of their features to learn more about them.

Power

Even though the S2 comes with a wall adapter and power chord, it does not feature a rechargeable battery, making it less portable than previous versions of this pump.

As a result, this pump is fine if you don’t have to move around much and are sitting at home or work, but it’s not the best solution if you have to walk around a lot in the house.

The Spectra 9 Plus breast pump is equipped with a rechargeable battery that offers enough power for around 3 hours of pumping time before the battery has to be recharged.

The fact that it is lightweight and portable means that you will find it a breeze to bring along with you on your trips!

Size And Weight

When it comes to Spectra devices, the 9 Plus model is their most portable one.

Considering that it is tiny enough to fit in your pocket or the palm of your hand and weighs just 239 g, it is a perfect solution for those who move around frequently and are not always able to pump in a comfortable location.

With dimensions of 20 by 20 by 18 cm and a weight of an amazing 1 kg, the S2 is by comparison a substantially bigger and heavier device. 

This means that rather than moving around with the machine when pumping, it is advisable to leave it on a desk while pumping instead.

Suction And Motor Capacity

While the 9 Plus has a higher suction strength than the S2, it is less powerful.

When it comes to suction settings, the Spectra 9 Plus would be a fantastic pick for moms who don’t mind working with low to medium levels of suction. 

The S2 is equipped with a more powerful and efficient motor than the 9 Plus. It is likely to last for multiple pumping sessions during the day.

Though it still has outstanding pumping capabilities, the S9 Plus is best suited to shorter, less regular pumping settings. 

Adjustable Settings

There are a total of 10 various levels for the expressive mode in Spectra 9 Plus, as well as 5 different levels for the massage mode. 

There are 12 various degrees of expressive mode to choose from on the S2, as well as 5 different levels of massage mode and 5 different cycle speeds to choose from.

With the Spectra 9 Plus, it is not possible to change the speed and suction independently of one another, as is the case with previous models. 

Because the cycle speed decreases or increases in proportion to the intensity of the suction, increasing or decreasing suction results in faster or slower cycling speeds.

However, you may change the speed of your S2 breast pump regardless of how strong the suction is being applied.

As a result, high suction strength and rapid cycle speed may both be achieved in the same machine at the same time.

Noise 

When constructing a Spectra pump, the needs of both the mother and the child are taken into account by the brand.

Even though both pumping devices are quite quiet and calm in operation, when we compare them, the S2 is far less loud than the Spectra 9 Plus. 

The fact that the S2 is quiet may be the deciding factor in a lot of moms choosing this pump. 

The Light

Even while this may appear to be a little detail, it may make a huge impact if you need to use the device at night or in the dark, or even if you just want to turn off or modify the built-in light on the device.

A built-in night light is available on the Spectra 9 Plus, but it can never be turned off and its brightness cannot be adjusted (some people even find it extremely bright).

The S2, on the other hand, features a nightlight with two levels of brightness that can be turned off completely.

So, Which Is Better – Spectra s9 vs s2? 

Both the Spectra 9 Plus and the Spectra S2 are excellent products.

Which one is better?

Well, that will depend on how you plan to pump.

The portable power source and lightweight of the Spectra 9 makes it the winner if you are looking for a breast pump that you can use while on the go.

Especially as the S2 needs to be plugged into an outlet to work, while the 9Plus does not.

However, if you are looking for an everyday pump with more adjustable settings then you should choose the S2 over the 9 Plus. 

No matter which breast pump you choose, you are guaranteed to get a very high-quality, durable, and powerful product.

Final Thoughts on Spectra s2 vs Spectra 9

Whilst it can be difficult to choose a breast pump, we think both the Spectra 9 and Spectra S2 are great breast pump options.

Overall, we would choose the Spectra S2 due to its adjustable suction levels, variable flow rates, and powerful pumping capabilities for every day use, however if you need a portable pump then the Spectra 9 is your better option.

We hope this guide on spectra 2 vs 9 has helped you decide which pump will best suit your needs.

And if you’re looking for more great guides, make sure to check out these guides on Lansinoh Smartpump 2.0 vs Spectra S2, Motif Luna vs Spectra S2, and best mini fridge for breast milk.