Motif Luna Vs Spectra S2

Are you trying to decide between Motif Luna Vs Spectra S2?

Then let us help you decide which is best for you and your baby: Motif Luna breast pump vs Spectra s2!

Choosing a breast pump can be a difficult task. The right breast pump can make a big difference to your life as a mother.

It can reduce the amount of time that you need to spend expressing milk, and it can make it a very comfortable experience rather than painful.

Many breastfeeding mothers choose to express milk for all or some of their baby’s feeds, so it is important to make sure that your breast pump is going to meet your needs. 

If you are looking for a breast pump then you have probably heard of the Motif Luna and the Spectra S2.

They are two of the most popular breast pumps on the market and have received lots of positive reviews.

But are they as good as people say? What makes these products so great? And which one is best?

If you need help choosing between Spectra S2 vs Motif Luna then look no further.

We have compared the two breast pumps, looking at their features, pros, and cons to help you decide which product is going to be best for you.

And if you love this Spectra 2 vs Motif Luna breast pump comparisons guide, make sure to check out our guides on Motif Luna vs Spectra 1, best pumping bra for Spectra, how to power pump with Spectra s2. Or even these reviews on Motif Luna Vs Medela Pump In Style and Motif Duo Vs Motif Luna!

This post contains affiliate links. See our full disclosure here

Motif Luna Vs Spectra S2

Let’s dive in and take a look how the Motif breast pump vs Spectra s2 compare.

All About Motif Luna Breast Pump

The Motif Luna is a double-sided electric breast pump with a moon shape.

This shape makes it comfortable to hold and fits nicely around the breast.

It has a large capacity, allowing you to store up to four ounces of expressed milk at once. 

It comes with a carrying strap so you don’t have to worry about carrying it around everywhere.

There are three settings available when using the Motif Luna. You can select either manual, semi-automatic or automatic mode.

In manual mode, you will manually trigger each pumping cycle by pressing down on the button. 

In semi-automatic mode, there is an indicator light that tells you how long you should wait before triggering another pumping cycle. Finally in automatic mode, the machine does everything for you!

There are many different accessories available for the Motif Luna including storage bottles, storage bags, nipple shields, and even a breast pad holder.

These accessories are designed to fit perfectly with the Motif Luna.

The Motif Luna also includes a cleaning brush. This allows you to clean the inside of the unit easily without having to remove any parts.

Pros

• Large capacity – stores up to 4 oz of milk at once
• Comfortable design
• Easy to use

Cons

• Not cordless
• Uses tubing

You can learn more in our full Motif Luna breast pump review!

All About Spectra S2 Breast Pump

The Spectra S2 is also a double-sided electric breast pump. It is shaped like a sphere and has a soft silicone exterior.

This design means that it is easy to clean and won’t leave any marks on your skin.

It has a large capacity, storing up to eight ounces of expressed milk. There are three settings available when you use the Spectra S2: manual, semi-automatic, and automatic.

In manual mode, you press down on the button to start and stop the pumping process. 

In semi-automatic, you can set the duration of the pumping cycle and the machine will automatically do this for you. In automatic mode, it will do everything for you. 

Like the Motif Luna, the Spectra S2 comes with several accessories such as storage bottles, storage bags, and nipple shields. These accessories are designed specifically for the Spectra S2 and work well together.

Pros

•  Large capacity – stores up to 8 oz of milk at once
•  Soft silicone exterior
•  Cordless
•  Includes storage accessories

Cons

• No cleaning brush included

You may also like this guide on Spectra S1 vs S2 vs S9.

Motif Luna Breast Pump Vs Spectra S2

Both the Motif Luna and Spectra S2 are double-sided electric breast pumps. Both machines can produce high-quality milk and come with a variety of accessories.

However, there are quite a few differences between Motif Luna vs Spectra 2 as we discuss below:

Shape

The Motif Luna is shaped like a moon and is very comfortable to hold. The Spectra S2 is shaped like a ball and is much smaller than the Motif Luna. 

Hospital Grade 

The Spectra S2 is a hospital-grade breast pump but the Motif Luna is not. 

Price 

The Spectra S2 tends to cost less than the Motif Luna, but both pumps are relatively comparable on price especially depending where you buy it from. 

Tubing 

The Motif Luna has an open system where the milk is transported from breast bottles via tubing. The Spectra S2 has a closed system which is easier to clean and is considered to be more hygienic.

Suction Settings 

The Motif Luna has two suction settings that will imitate the suction of a nursing baby. This is a natural method of encouraging the breast to express milk.

The Spectra S2 is more advanced as it has these two settings, but also gives you additional control over the speed and the power of the suction. 

This means that the milk expression is likely to be more efficient with the Spectra S2. 

Pump Bag

The Motif Luna comes with a storage bag which is very useful for transporting the pump. The Spectra S2 does not come with a storage bag though you can purchase one separately from the manufacturer. 

What Are The Similarities Between The Two Pumps?

Whilst there are some differences between the Motif Luna and the Spectra S2, there are also some features that they share:

Double-Sided 

Both of these breast pumps are double-sided but can also be used as single-sided when needed. This means that you can express milk from both breasts at once, or you can breastfeed and use the pump to collect milk from the other breast. 

Noise 

Both of these breast pumps are considered to be fairly quiet when they operate. This is ideal when it comes to nighttime pumping, or pumping in the same room as a sleeping baby or partner. 

Display 

Both of these breast pumps benefit from an LCD display which makes it easy to use the pump at night or in a dark room without needing to use a lamp. 

Power 

Both of these electric breast pumps need to be plugged into a power source to work, so you cannot use them on the go or move around while you are pumping. 

Accessories 

Whilst the Motif Luna comes with a bag and the Spectra S2 doesn’t, they both come with breast shields and milk bottles included. 

Auto Shut Off

Both breast pumps have a very useful auto shut-off feature. This means that the breast pump will automatically turn off if you have been using it for half an hour.

This means that you safely take a nap when you are breast pumping without worrying about having to wake up to switch off the motor.

So, Which Is Better – Motif Luna or Spectra S2? 

Both of these products are highly rated and come recommended by many mothers.

They both have some excellent features like a backlit display, an automatic shut-off, and the ability to be used double-sided or single-sided. 

Neither of these breast pumps is entirely hands-free or allows you to move around freely while you are pumping.

They both require that the cords be plugged into a power source during use, which means you have to stay in one position while you are pumping.

Both of the pumps have a good milk capacity which should be suitable for most women. 

The Motif Luna is a great choice if you want something simple and reliable. It is affordable and easy to use.

It comes with a storage bag and it has a comfortable shape. However, it is only designed to mimic the suction of a newborn baby.

If you are looking for a more advanced breast pump then the Spectra S2 may be the better option. It is much more advanced than the Motif Luna.

It offers several different functions including adjustable suction levels, variable flow rates, and a range of different cup sizes.

The Spectra S2 is also quieter than the Motif Luna, meaning that you can use this pump during the day or night without waking anyone else up.

The Motif Luna has a maximum noise level of 85dB whereas the Spectra S2’s noise level is just 65dB.

The Spectra S2 is a hospital-grade breast pump so you know you are getting a premium product. Despite this, it is still very affordable and is often cheaper than the Motif Luna.

It has a closed system which is much easier to keep clean, saving you time and hassle. 

Taking everything into consideration, the Spectra S2 seems to be the superior product and it is also the best value for money. This would be our recommendation, though both products will do a good job. 

Final Thoughts on Spectra S2 vs Motif Luna

Whilst it can be difficult to choose a breast pump, we think both the Motif Luna and Spectra S2 are great breast pump options.

Overall, we would choose the Spectra S2 due to its adjustable suction levels, variable flow rates, and a range of different cup sizes as well as it’s lower price.

We hope this guide on Motif vs Spectra has helped you decide which pump will best suit your needs.

And if you’re looking for more great guides, make sure to check out these guides on Haakaa breast pump review, best mini fridge for breast milk, and best bottles for breastfed babies.