Motif Luna Vs Spectra S1 Breast Pump

Are you trying to decide between Motif Luna Vs Spectra S1?

Then let us help you decide which is best for you and your baby: Spectra s1 vs Motif Luna breast pump!

If you’re looking to buy breast pumps, you’ve probably come across the Spectra S1 and the Motif Luna pumps at the top of many ‘Best Of’ lists.

These brands are market leaders and direct competitors, and both of these pumps are highly recommended.

These breast pumps are comparable in terms of size, pumping capacity, and user-friendliness.

According to several reviews, the components are interchangeable between the Luna and Spectra S1!

While both pumps are excellent at expressing milk, there are a few major distinctions between them that may make one a better choice for your pumping circumstances.

So, if you need help choosing between Motif Luna breast pump vs Spectra s1 then look no further.

We have compared the two breast pumps, looking at their features, pros, and cons to help you decide which product is going to be best for you.

And if you love this Spectra 1 vs Motif Luna breast pump comparisons guide, make sure to check out our guides on Motif Luna vs Spectra S2, Motif Luna vs Medela Pump In Style, Medela Symphony Vs Spectra S1, and Spectra S1 vs S2. Or even our Motif Duo Vs Motif Luna review!

This post contains affiliate links. See our full disclosure here

Motif Luna Vs Spectra S1

Let’s dive in and take a look how the Motif breast pump vs Spectra s1 pump compare.

All About Spectra S1

The Spectra S1 pump is a closed-loop breast pump that comes equipped with everything you need to begin pumping immediately.

With your purchase, you get 2 bottles, lids, and tubing. You will also get two of each size flange. 

This pump is pretty nice to operate and features straightforward controls. Its strength and speed can be adjusted effortlessly, and the large, clear digital display makes it straightforward to identify and pick your preferred settings.

Additionally, the clarity of the information provided on the display makes it straightforward to repeat the cycle and keep the same settings from the previous pumping session.

The Spectra S1 has a rechargeable battery, which enables you to continue pumping even when you are not connected to an electrical outlet.

This is particularly advantageous if you have more youngsters to chase or want to pump while doing activities like cooking. 

Pros

• Very Powerful- even on hospital-grade pumps, it is rare to find a breast pump with as much suction power as the S1 has. 
• Perfect for mothers who struggle with milk supply – if you never seem to have enough of a milk supply for your baby, the S1 can stimulate your milk glands as it pumps. This triggers more milk to be produced
• Comfortable – though it has very powerful suction, the S1 does not hurt as it pumps. The S1 vibrates slightly, which mimics the way a baby would breastfeed. This will feel more natural and comfortable for you
• Very quiet – like the Luna pump, the S1 is super quiet and can be used around sleeping babies without worrying about waking them up

Cons

• Large – this pump is massive, and if you wish to take it somewhere, you may find it annoying how heavy it is as well. You will probably need a whole separate bag to carry this pump in
• Always in expression mode – when turned on, this pump will always start in expression mode, which is annoying as almost all moms need to go through the massage mode to begin expressing milk

​All About Motif Luna

The Motif Luna is a double-sided electric breast pump with a moon shape.

This shape makes it comfortable to hold and fits nicely around the breast.

It has a large capacity, allowing you to store up to four ounces of expressed milk at once. 

It comes with a carrying strap so you don’t have to worry about carrying it around everywhere.

There are three settings available when using the Motif Luna. You can select either manual, semi-automatic or automatic mode.

In manual mode, you will manually trigger each pumping cycle by pressing down on the button. 

In semi-automatic mode, there is an indicator light that tells you how long you should wait before triggering another pumping cycle. Finally in automatic mode, the machine does everything for you!

There are many different accessories available for the Motif Luna including storage bottles, storage bags, nipple shields, and even a breast pad holder.

These accessories are designed to fit perfectly with the Motif Luna.

The Motif Luna also includes a cleaning brush. This allows you to clean the inside of the unit easily without having to remove any parts.

Pros

• Closed-system– this is the most hygienic of the two systems used in breast pumps. There is little to no chance that your milk will become contaminated, as there is no way for mold to grow or for condensation to build-up
• Very quiet – at just 45 decibels, this is a super quiet pump that won’t disturb anyone when you use it. It also helps in making the pump more discreet
• Adjustable settings – being able to adjust the speed of the pump cycle is very useful. You can also adjust the suction
• Powerful – this pump offers a very powerful suction, which is great for women who want to get every last drop out 

Cons

• Massage mode – this mode is not very strong on the Luna. The massage mode is there to get your breasts into let down mode, after which milk starts flowing. If you struggle to get into let down, then this pump may not be strong enough for you
• No handle – this is only a little thing but it is a bit inconvenient that this pump does not have a carry handle as this would make taking it places much easier

You can learn more in our full Motif Luna breast pump review!

Similarities and Differences Between Spectra s1 vs Motif Luna Breast Pump

Now you’ve got a better understanding of these breast pumps individually, let’s compare some of the key product features.

Size 

The size difference between the Luna and the S1 is one of the most visible differences between the two models.

The Spectra S1 is distinguished by a raised handle that gives the impression of being larger.

However, the Motif Luna is smaller in comparison to the Spectra S1 when it comes to the overall size and weight.

The Luna pump weighs 2.3 pounds and is 7 inches x 8 inches x 2.25 inches (L x W x H) in size. 

The S1 is significantly larger in both the weight and size categories. This pump weighs 2.7 pounds and is 7.9 inches x 7.9 inches, and 6.7 inches ( L x W x H) in size. 

Suction Power

The suction power of the S1 is up to 270 mmHg, whilst the suction power of the Motif Luna is up to 280 mmHg.

While it would seem that the Luna is the winner in this category, a higher suction may not be right for your needs, so the S1 might still be right for you.

Using the most suction power available will only be effective if you are pumping at the highest achievable rate. 

Realistically, you will probably not need to pump the maximum amount of milk, as this will be too much for your baby, and will probably make your breasts very sore as well. 

But if you want to get as much milk as you possibly can, you will be grateful for the better suction. 

Pump Settings

There is some variance in cycle speed accessible between the Spectra S1 and the Motif Luna, even though both of these pumps have more flexible pump settings when compared to other pumps. 

The Motif Luna progresses through the pump cycle slower than the Spectra S1, which is a good thing.

The cycle speed in massage mode is fixed at 70 CPM in the Spectra S1 and 60 CPM in the Motif Luna. 

In the express mode, both pumps give a different range of cycle speeds.

The cycle speed of Spectra S1 is between 38 and 54 CPM, whilst the cycle speed of the Luna is between 30-and 46 CPM.

So how will this affect you?

As anyone with breast pump experience will tell you, different cycle speeds work for different women. What worked for you may not work for your friend. 

Moms who respond better and pump more breast milk when the cycle speed is lowered are more common than mothers who respond better and pump more breast milk when the cycle speed is raised.

So what will be the right speed for you?

You should choose a tempo that is as similar as possible to the rhythm of your baby’s sucking, as this will help the pump to feel as natural as breastfeeding would. 

The Modes

When using Spectra S1 it will always switch on during expression mode.

Because women frequently begin pumping in massage mode when they first begin pumping, some moms find this a bit irritating.

When switched on, the Luna can start on the last mode you were on, or you can change it before you begin pumping.

For convenience when using Luna, it is recommended that you always return it to massage mode before turning it off.

Power

Both of these pumps are battery-operated, with the batteries themselves being rechargeable.

This means that you are easily able to pump on the go, whether you be at home, at work, or spending the day out with your newborn. 

Keep in mind though the battery life of both the batteries in the S1 and the Luna is only 2-3 hours, after which they will need to be charged again. 

Closed – System

Both the S1 and the Luna breast pumps are closed-system devices.

This means that the breast pumps are fitted with a barrier that stops the milk from entering the pump motor or tubes during the pumping process.

This is a common occurrence with open-system pumps. In these devices, small drops of milk can enter the tubes of the pump.

Condensation can also build up easily. Both of these things can cause mold to grow in the tubes, which can then contaminate the milk. 

While this can be avoided by cleaning the tubes well, as they are so small and thin it is very difficult to do so. 

All of this means that closed-system pumps are a favorite among parents, as they are easier to use, clean, and are much more hygienic. 

Noise 

The S1 and the Luna are both whisper-quiet pumps, with them producing noise levels of 45 dB or less. This has two main benefits.

First, it makes these pumps more discreet, so you may feel comfortable using them at work as they will not disturb anyone. 

Second, as they are so quiet you can pump in the same room as your sleeping baby or partner without worrying about waking them up. 

Hospital Grade

Both the S1 and the Luna have been recognized as “hospital-grade” breast pumps.

Essentially, this means that they are sturdy and heavy-duty enough to survive the continuous and repeated pumping that they will be subject to. 

They also have a substantial amount of suction power at their maximum capacity.

Breast pumps such as this would be an ideal alternative for individuals who need to pump often throughout the day. 

Final Thoughts on Luna Motif vs Spectra s1

Whilst it can be difficult to choose a breast pump, we think both the Motif Luna and Spectra S1 are great breast pump options.

Overall, we would choose the Motif Luna breast pump due to its smaller size and lighter weight as well as it’s lower price.

We hope this guide on Motif vs Spectra S1 has helped you decide which pump will best suit your needs.

And if you’re looking for more great guides, make sure to check out these guides on best lactation supplements, best mini fridge for breast milk, and best bottles for breastfed babies.