Freemie Vs Elvie

Trying to decide between wearable electric breast pumps Freemie vs Elvie?

Then check out our Elvie vs Freemie comparison guide, to learn more about what both brands have to offer.

Freemie and Elvie are both leaders in the wearable breast pump market.

Both brands created game changing designs, intended to revolutionize how moms pumped.

Rather than bulky pumps that required wall sockets, these electric pumps slipped neatly into the bra.

For moms, this offers freedom and ease. You can pump on the go, as you move around the house, or as you slump in front of the TV!

Working moms can benefit from the wearable breast pump, as they’re easy to use in an office setting.

But while some electric breast pumps prioritize discretion (such as Elvie), others go for power (like Freemie) it can be hard to know which one is the right choice for you.

So, in this guide, we’ve taken a deep dive into the Elvie Pump vs Freemie, including their features, pro, and cons so you can easily decide which is the right breast pump for you!

And if you love our Freemie Pump vs Elvie review, then you love our guides on Freemie vs Willow breast pump, Elvie vs Spectra breast pump, Momcozy vs Elvie, Elvie Catch vs Curve, and Elvie vs Willow breast pump!

This post contains affiliate links. See our full disclosure here

Freemie VS Elvie

We’ll start by taking a close look at what Freemie and Elvie have to offer.

All About Freemie

Freemie was one of the first brands to really explore the potential of the wearable electric breast pump.

Nowadays, the Freemie range includes multiple wearable pump options, including cups that can be used with other brands!

Freemie breast pumps attach compact, shaped cups to a small pump hub, with limited cords and tubes.

The pumps are slimline, and designed to slip neatly under your clothes.

There are several pump options in the Freemie brand, including the Liberty, Rose, and Independence. 

Freemie breast pumps are easy to use, with handy features such as Auto Shutoff and Memory settings.

The high suction makes them a good choice for moms who want to pump regularly, even if the slightly bulky build isn’t the best for portable discretion.

However, the low price of the Freemie pumps helps to offset many of their faults.

You can learn more in our full Freemie Breast Pump review!

Pros

• Freemie sells affordable wearable electric breast pumps.
• The Turbo mode offers multiple levels, so you can pump efficiently and comfortably.
• The Freemie cups can be attached to other branded pumps, to help you create a system that really works for you.
• An LCD screen shows timings and settings, so you can pump at your pace.
• The hospital-grade suction of Freemie pumps provides an efficient performance.

Cons

• Despite being portable, the Freemie pumps are a little bulky.
• Although the Freemie pumps have some useful features, they lack the smart sophistication of premium pumps.

All About Elvie

Elvie are pushing the limits of the breast pump, prioritizing convenience for moms as well as babies to make intuitive designs.

Compact, lightweight, and packed with smart features, these pumps truly define discretion,

The Elvie wearable electric breast pump range began with the Elvie Pump.

This incredibly compact all-in-one pump is still one of the best portable breast pumps on the market.

Featuring top Piezo pump technology and smart infrared sensors, you can pump quietly and intuitively.

Elvie also sells the Elvie Stride, a slightly larger pump with hospital-grade suction as well as the Elvie Curve which is a manual breast pump.

There isn’t much to complain about with the Elvie pumps themselves. However, to access these incredible features, prepare for a high price tag.

You can learn more in our Elvie Breast Pump review, Elvie Stride vs Elvie Pump, and the best bra for Elvie Pump guides.

Pros

• The Elvie Pump uses Piezo pumps and a compact build to create quiet discretion.
• Connected to the Pump with Elvie app, moms can access smart features with ease.
• The premium finish ensures a gentle and comfortable pump, with adjustable levels.
• The Elvie Stride has a powerful hospital-grade suction measuring -300 mmHg.
• All Elvie electric pumps are incredibly quiet.

Cons

• Elvie is expensive.

Similarities And Differences Between Freemie VS Elvie

There are key differences between Freemie and Elvie, and these differences can help you find the right pump for you.

Let’s dive in.

Discretion

One of the major benefits of wearable electric pumps is their discretion. That doesn’t just mean that others won’t notice you pumping.

It also means the pumps don’t get in the way as you go about your day to day.

The Elvie Pump is all about discretion. The curved and compact design features no tubes or cords, and it slips easily into the bra.

With infrared sensors detecting as the cup fills and automatically pausing when you’re nearly done, the Elvie Pump can be used with minimal interruption.

It’s also close to silent, with Piezo pumps creating a gentle and quiet oscillation.

The Elvie Stride is relatively discreet, but it can’t compare to the Pump. And neither can any of the Freemie designs.

All these pumps come with cords, which can be tricky to hide under your clothing. They also have central control hubs, although these are small.

Freemie have designed the Rose pump to provide the best discretion, although it lags behind the Elvie Pump.

However, the slimline cups, noise reduction technology, and sleep timer make it a stealthy pump.

Levels And Modes

The suction power on all the Freemie pumps is impressive.

Featuring hospital-grade suction (~280 mmHg), these powerful pumps allow you to efficiently empty your breasts.

And with the independent Turbo power controls, there are over 100 settings to choose from. The Freemie pumps allow you to pump in a way that’s right for you.

The Elvie Pump has sacrificed some suction for portability. At roughly 220 mmHg, this pump isn’t great for anyone with low milk.

However, there are numerous settings to create a more comfortable suction.

The Elvie Stride offers improved suction, with a hospital grade -300 mmHg. The Stride also has more levels than the Pump, for better adjustments.

Portability

One of the benefits of the wearable pump is that you can move around with it. So, just how portable are these pumps?

The Elvie Pump is one of the most portable breast pumps on the market.

Small, lightweight, and with no cables or tubes, it’s super simple to travel with the Elvie Pump.

The Stride is a little bulkier, and has more parts, but it still fits into a purse. 

The Freemie pumps are similar to the Elvie Stride. These are pumps connected to cups via cords, which will always add some bulk.

If it’s portability you’re after, we recommend the Freemie Rose. It’s compatible with the smaller, 5 oz cups.

Comfort

Both Freemie and Elvie sell shields and flanges in different sizes to suit different nipples. These ensure the best suction and the best comfort.

If the shield doesn’t fit properly, pumping can be sore, so a range of sizes is useful.

The premium finish of the Elvie pumps offer a gentle suction that feels incredibly comfortable.

Lightweight, the cups won’t weigh you down. And as they can be controlled from your phone, there’s no reaching into your bra for adjustments.

Freemie cups are comfortable, but they don’t have the same gentle touch of the Elvie pumps. 

Additional Features

The Elvie Pump and Elvie Stride both connect to the Pump with Elvie app — and that’s packed full of features.

The app allows you to track your sessions and preferred settings, as well as keep an eye on how much you’ve pumped.

With the app connected, you can use the Elvie pump without awkwardly adjusting your bra, and you can check when you last pumped (if baby brain is causing problems).

In comparison, the Freemie pumps seem a little basic. There is no smart app, but the pump itself has some useful features.

An LCD screen makes it easier to track your settings, auto shutoff prevents excess pumping, and the memory settings allow you to quickly find your favorite settings.

It might not do quite as much as the Elvie app, but the Freemie pumps still have useful features.

And a recent redesign has made the pumps more intuitive than ever. 

Price

Elvie is a premium brand, and the Elvie Pump is an expensive breast pump. The Elvie Stride is around half the price, but it still isn’t cheap.

However, you do get what you pay for with Elvie. Those smart features and premium finishes are reflected in the price tag.

If you can afford it, the Elvie pumps offer a high level of performance.

The Freemie pumps are significantly cheaper, with most of the double pumps costing less than an Elvie Pump single cup.

Again, this is reflected in the performance. The Freemie pumps might not cost as much as Elvie, but they also do less.

Freemie cups are also compatible with pumps from other brands, such as Medela, Spectra, and Philips Avent.

So, if you have a second hand pump, but you don’t like the idea of using a second hand cup, you can invest in the comfortable Freemie cups and save money.

Final Thoughts On Freemie VS Elvie

Elvie and Freemie meet similar needs for moms, but the brands themselves have quite different offerings.

It’s hard to beat the Elvie Pump for on the go discretion. Incredibly compact and whisper quiet, even working moms will be able to pump without anyone noticing.

But for the premium Elvie products, you have to pay a premium price.

Freemie isn’t quite as high tech as Elvie, but these are still powerful pumps with slim builds.

If you regularly pump at the office, the Freemie pumps might feel slightly conspicuous. But for pumping at home, they won’t get in the way.

So, do you want ultimate discretion? Or well priced power?

We hope this guide has helped you learn the differences between Freemie and Elvie, to find the right breast pump for you!

And if you’re looking for more great guides, make sure to check out these guides on best breast pumps for twins, best breast pumps for low milk supply, and best portable breast pumps for travel. Or even our guides on the best lactation supplements and best breastmilk storage bags.