Hate to see milk go to waste? The Elvie Curve and Elvie Catch can ensure no breast milk gets lost. Find out which is right for you with this guide: Elvie Catch vs Curve!
Every drop of breast milk is precious, and the last thing you want is to lose ounces soaking into your bra. Not only is it a frustrating waste, but wet patches can be a little embarrassing (if perfectly normal).
Moms have used manual pumps and breast pads to help make the most of their milk supply, and avoid leaks. Elvie might be a brand better known for their revolutionary electric breast pumps, but their manual offerings are also pretty exciting.
Elvie Catch and Elvie Curve are silicone cups designed to help moms capture more of their milk. Find out how the Catch and Curve can add to your pumping routine, with this comparison guide.
In this guide, we’ve taken a deep dive into the Elvie Catch vs Elvie Curve, including their features, pro, and cons so you can easily decide which is the best Elvie breast pump for you!
And if you love our Elvie Curve vs Catch review, then you love these guides on Elvie Stride vs Elvie Pump, Elvie Curve vs Haakaa, Momcozy vs Elvie and Freemie vs Elvie. Or even our on the best portable breast pumps for travel!
This post contains affiliate links. See our full disclosure here
Elvie Catch Vs Curve
In this section, we’ll take a look at what the Elvie Catch and the Elvie Curve actually are, and what they can do for you.
All About Elvie Catch
The Elvie Catch is designed to replace disposable breast pads, and catch milk between pumping and breastfeeding sessions. The small silicone cup fits easily into the bra, where it collects leaks as you carry on with your day.
Subtle shaping helps the Elvie Catch fit discreetly into the bra. In fact, it’s so discreet, you might even forget it’s there! Made from a soft food safe silicone, the Elvie Catch creates a gentle yet secure suction against the skin.
Able to hold 1 oz of milk (per cup), when your Elvie Catch is full, use the teardrop opening to decant your rescued milk. The Catch can then be washed by hand (it’s just two pieces), or put in the dishwasher.
For heavy leakers and those just starting breastfeeding, the easy convenience of the Elvie Catch can help ensure no milk gets wasted.
- Slim and curved, the Catch fits easily into a bra.
- A slip-proof silicone skirt keeps the Curve in place.
- The two-piece design is easy to clean, and can be placed in the dishwasher.
- A teardrop opening makes it easy to decant, so you don’t spill any carefully saved milk.
- 1 oz capacity, thanks to the raised nipple design.
- The Elvie Catch is expensive, even for a reusable cup.
- Elvie recommends taking off the Catch after two to three hours, which might not work for your body/schedule.
All About Elvie Curve
The Elvie Curve is a manual in-bra breast pump designed to catch bonus milk. Able to slip easily in the bra and activated with just a single push, it’s fantastic for capturing excess milk on one side while you breastfeed or pump on the other.
The Elvie Curve is a simple design, made from just two pieces. The soft silicone feels comfortable on the skin, and the curved design fits easily against the breast. Discrete, the Curve can slip into your bra, and a press of the soft silicone starts expression.
For both comfort and convenience, the Elvie Curve comes with the Valve. A press of the Valve adjusts suction, and releases the Curve when you’re done. So, no more pinched skin!
The Curve can hold 4 oz of milk, which makes it a little bulky. However, compared to other manual breast pumps, the all-in-bra design is surprisingly discreet.
- Catch up to 4 oz of bonus milk when you’re breastfeeding, pumping, or feeling full.
- An all-in-bra design, the Curve is comfortable to wear and relatively discrete.
- Easy to use, just a press on the silicone gets the suction going.
- Dishwasher safe and easy to clean.
- The soft silicone front means you can lie the Curve down when it’s full, and not lose any milk.
- The Elvie Curve is a little expensive for a manual breast pump.
- The suction is weak.
Similarities And Differences Between Elvie Catch And Curve
Both the Elvie Curve and Elvie Catch achieve the same goal, but use different methods to get there. In this section, we’ll explore those differences and similarities.
Elvie has prioritized both comfort and convenience with the Elvie Catch and Curve. Both made from food safe silicone that’s soft against the skin, these pumps feel natural. The Catch and Curve are both free from BPA and phthalates, so they’re safe for moms and babies.
The Elvie Curve uses valve pressure to stay in place, and this valve can also be used to adjust the suction. When you’re done pumping, release the pressure using the Valve, and the Curve comes loose (with no skin pinching).
A silicone skirt helps the Elvie Catch stay in place, and ensure a soft touch on the skin. This close seal provides confidence, as well as comfort — you know it won’t fall off.
The Elvie Curve provides manual expression with a difference. It’s fuss free, easy to do, and effective.
To get the Elvie Curve going, you simply need to get the pump in place, and press the silicone pouch. This will start a continuous natural suction. When you need a little more, press the pouch again, and your milk will keep flowing.
There are many uses for the gentle suction of the Elvie Curve. It can be used during let down, or when you’re feeling uncomfortably full. However, the Elvie Curve has a weaker suction than similar brands. Don’t expect full drainage.
The Elvie Catch doesn’t have any suction at all. This is exclusively for catching leaks in between pumping.
Hands-free and able to slip into your bra, the Elvie Curve is one of the most discreet manual pumps around.
The Curve is so discreet, even your baby won’t notice it’s there! Tuck the Curve into your bra when breastfeeding, and your little one won’t be able to kick it off.
Because of the 4oz capacity, the Curve isn’t exactly hidden in the bra. However, the natural shaping means it doesn’t stand out. It’s definitely more discreet than traditional manual pumps!
It will be hard to spot the Catch under your clothing, thanks to the natural shaping. The gentle curving of the Elvie Catch, combined with the wide and slim build, makes it almost invisible when in the bra. Although we can’t guarantee a perfect fit (all bodies are different), the Catch is very adaptable.
Having gone through all that effort to prevent any breast milk getting lost, the last thing you want to do is tip half of it away when it’s time to decant.
Once you’re done pumping, the Elvie Curve can be laid on the silicone front, to prevent any milk leaking. Then, it can be easily decanted using the nipple opening.
The Catch has a teardrop design opening, making it easy to pour out all the milk you’ve collected. You need to be a little careful the first few times you remove the Catch from your bra to avoid spills, but other than that, it’s easy to decant.
The Elvie Catch has a 1 oz capacity per cup. This isn’t a huge capacity, but it should be enough to catch leaking between pumps. And the raised nipple holes give more space for milk inside the cup. Keeping the cup small adds to the discretion of the Elvie Catch, so this is a feature, rather than a bug.
Elvie recommends removing the Catch every two to three hours, and giving the nipples time to dry out.
The Curve has a 4 oz capacity.
A simple, two-part design makes both the Elvie Catch and Curve easy to clean. Once you’ve finished using your pump, all you need to do is separate the two pieces, and sterilize with boiling water. You can even put your Elvie in the dishwasher!
Once clean and dry, simply put the pieces back together, and they’re ready to use again.
The Elvie Curve does more than the Catch, so it’s no surprise that this is the more expensive item.
The Catch isn’t hugely expensive, but it is more expensive than a pack of breast pads. However, if you’re choosing between disposable breast pads and the Elvie Catch, the reusable Catch can save you money over time.
It’s worth noting that Elvie is a more expensive brand, and similar cups to the Catch are available for cheaper. Elvie does, however, make high quality and durable items, so it might be worth investing in the brand name.
Final Thoughts On Elvie Curve Vs Catch
The Elvie Catch and Curve are wearable cups designed to help you save any leaking milk, so nothing goes to waste. The Elvie Curve has some suction, while the Catch collects leaks.
Overall, we love the added suction of the Curve. It isn’t the most powerful suction, so don’t expect total drainage. However, it can be used to capture leaks, and prevent waste when you’re pumping or feeding.
However, the Catch is a cheaper, and more discreet option. If you’re looking to stop wet patches as you go about your day, try the Catch!
No one wants to see breast milk go to waste, and with the Elvie Catch or Curve, you don’t have to! We hope this guide will help you find the cup to make the most of your pumping experience.
And if you’re looking for more great guides, make sure to check out these guides on Spectra S1 Vs S2 Vs S9, Spectra vs Elvie breast pump review, and Elvie vs Willow pump. Or even our guides on the best lactation supplements and best breastmilk storage bags.