Best Pacifiers For Newborns

Are you trying to the best pacifiers for newborns?

Then let us help you decide which is best for you and your newborn baby with our guide to the best pacifiers for newborn baby!

Pacifiers come by many different names; a binky, soother, dummy, or bo-bo, but no matter what name you call it, a pacifier can be a must for many new parents.

Pacifiers help sooth and settle your baby by pacifying their innate need to suck.

But what are the best baby pacifiers? And how do you choose one?

Well to help you decide, we have compiled a list of the best pacifiers for new born babies, looking at their features, pros, and cons so you can easily find a pacifier that your new born baby will love.

To make things easier for you, we have also included a handy buyer’s guide so you know everything you need to know to make the right decision on what pacifier is the right choice for you.

And if you love this best soother for newborn guide, make sure to check out our guides on best pacifiers for breastfed babies, best preemie pacifiers, and how many pacifiers do I need.

This post contains affiliate links. See our full disclosure here

List of 5 Best Pacifiers For Newborns

Best Pacifier For Newborn

1. MAM Original Start Newborn Baby Pacifier

This pacifier is truly ideal for a baby who wants encouraging breastfeeding, a pacifier which creates solutions to SIDS, as well as newborn babies in general.

The design of this pacifier is ideal, it has a symmetrical shape, allowing you to put the pacifier ‘upside down’ with no fear of it causing your baby issues.

The silicone nipple is BPA-free and also attempts to imitate a real nipple to help with breastfeeding.

Another great design feature which helps prevent SIDS is the little airway holes.

The design allows the baby to have guaranteed airflow should they spit it out, it won’t have any chance of smothering their mouth.

Moreover, the design means that the baby’s airflow to their nose is unimpeded should their oral airflow be impeded, this also allows their skin to breathe.

A great and unique feature is the self sterilizing case which comes with your purchase.

As your purchase affords you two pacifiers, the idea with this is that the one you are washing can be replaced with the fresh one, so your baby doesn’t get confused.

Although, the pacifier takes a mere three minutes to clean.

The self sanitizing case is a simple case where you fill water and palace in the microwave for three minutes and the heat gets rid of any dangerous bacteria, perfectly clean for your child.

The heat of the pacifier post cleaning, once cooled, can help mimic the warmth of a breast.

Pros

• Focus on SIDS prevention
• Two in a pack
• Choice of design

Cons

• Silicone perhaps not the best material to mimic human nipple
• Rigidity might make it hard to stay in babies mouth, could do with some flex

2. Nanobebe Baby Pacifiers

This is another optimized product which seeks to prevent SIDS and provide a pacifier, which is great for helping newborns breastfeed by avoiding nipple confusion.

A unique feature we enjoyed was how the ergonomic design of the pacifier allows it to naturally fit the baby’s mouth.

This ergonomic design also means that there is some flex as the baby sucks, this means that the pacifier stays in their mouth more often than not.

The natural silicone design is BPA free, perhaps not the most optimal for nipple mimicking, but still better than most materials.

The whole thing is also one piece, this thing will never break into more than one piece, so there’s no chance the baby will swallow this.

Moreover, this one piece design has little air holes so if smothering did occur then it would not be fatal.

The pacifier can be thrown in the dishwasher with safety and also comes in a 2 pack so that you can rotate while one is being cleaned.

Pros

• One piece design is super safe
• Super SIDS focused
• BPA Free

Cons

• Again, silicone is not the optimal material to avoid nipple confusion, but is one of the best.

3. Boon Jewl Orthodontic Silicone Pacifier

These pacifiers are really fun and unique.

They all come as one piece which is great, air holes help prevent smothering or SIDS from occurring within the whole piece design which is made of pure BPA free silicone.

The little ‘jewl’, or the nipple of the pacifier, is a patented design that is created by a pediatric dentist.

In other words, the nipple is designed to encourage latching, this specific orthodontic design essentially trains the babies mouth and tongue for optimal latching and feeding.

This can be a big help when the baby is not breastfeeding properly, but you need them to relax.

The actual one piece design sort of flares out where the babies nose and chin would be, as this moves away from the babies face it makes for a comfy sucking motion as well as the fact that it leaves airflow for the baby to breathe if they spit it out.

A useful handle as part of the one piece design makes it super easy to remove.

Another thing Boon Jewl push in the marketing is that the block colors they choose are a fun design that is gender-neutral but can also match anything you choose for the baby to wear, so no ruined baby pics with this.

Pros

• Orthodontic design to nipple
• One piece design
• Air holes and flared edges make airflow great
• Dishwasher safe

Cons

• The hole in the handle could catch on things and be pulled out

4. Philips AVENT Soothie Pacifier

Parents absolutely love this pacifier mainly because it is used in many hospitals across our great nation, yet is commercially available too.

When something is used in hospitals you can be pretty sure that it is going to be super safe, a hospital will want to avoid any discrepancy that would lead to legal action as much as possible.

One thing this does mean is that the silicone used will be ‘hospital grade’ suggesting it is super, super safe, although even in this case we think there is still a better material than silicone to use to mimic a mother’s nipple.

An orthodontic nipple is a big point for marketing, but this product actually uses a cone shape which might not be the most ideal for mimicking the shape of a nipple, nor would this be considered that orthodontic.

The marketing claims this ‘respects’ the babies’ gum and teeth growth and is better for their teeth.

One unique and interesting feature is that the pacifier has an orifice on the other side of the nipple to that which the baby places its mouth on.

You are supposed to put your finger in this hole as it ‘promotes bonding’ with the baby and reduces nipple confusion.

Pros

• Easy grip to pull from babies mouth, safe also
• 4 in a pack for similar price to others
• ‘Hospital grade’ materials
• SIDS focused

Cons

• We think that there is a better shape for the nipple on this product

5. Tommee Tippee Newborn Pacifier

This product is interesting and has some fun features that parents may prefer. The main draw of the pacifier is the interesting circular design.

A concave circle protrudes the nipple, but surrounding the nipple are many holes.

This design is super effective at preventing SIDS; there is almost no chance of airways being blocked.

Another great advantage of this design means that there is almost nothing touching the baby’s face, they will only be sucking on the nipple and rarely ever come into contact with the rest of the one piece design.

The nipple’s conical shape could be better, other studies suggest a more square and flat design is better for breastfeeding training.

The nipple remains the right size, even though the size seems to go up to 6 months. The pacifier also washes well in the washing machine.

Pros

• No part of the design touches baby’s face apart from nipple
• Super SIDS prevention
• Good to skin

Cons

• Nipple could be shaped better.

Buying Guide on Top Rated Pacifier For Newborn

When buying a pacifier for your newborn baby, you want something that will help your baby develop good habits while they are still young.

If you buy a pacifier that isn’t right for your baby, then you may end up having issues later down the line. You should look at the following factors before choosing a pacifier:

Shape

A pacifier nipple should imitate the real nipple of a female, the idea is that his shape helps them use their mouth and tongue in the necessary way they need to in order to latch and feed properly when breastfeeding from a mother.

A straight, flat, or bulb shaped nipple is totally okay for a newborn pacifier, yet an orthodontic pacifier designed like a natural nipple, slightly square and flat, is the most recommended shape to help with breastfeed.

These ‘non-orthodontic’ shapes will often be the bulb shaped nipples that are not imitative of a biological nipple.

Material

Most pacifiers will either be made from silicone, natural rubber, or latex due to the materials being BPA free – you should always check anything going in your baby’s mouth is BPA free.

The natural rubber pacifier will also be free from other non-desirable chemicals such as PVC, parabens, etc., however this material does not provide the flexibility that latex gives.

Latex is the most recommended for newborn babies to practice latching and feeding.

Be aware some parents and babies will have latex allergies, so make sure you know this already, as this won’t be the most fun way to figure out an allergy to latex.

Size

Of course, size is a big thing when it comes to pacifiers, and what seems most obvious to parents who are worried about SIDS – did you know that pacifiers actually come in different sizes?

The size of pacifier you should offer a newborn should be one of the smaller sizes.

Although, most pacifiers often have a labeled size – this can be clearly marked as ‘0 – 3 months’ or ‘NB to 3M’.

Design

The biggest thing you want to avoid in order to avoid SIDS is design flaws that cause airways to be blocked, particularly the nose, as well as other airways.

This often appears in the design parts of a pacifier that are aesthetic rather than practical.

Moreover, anything that isn’t one whole piece is going to cause serious trouble when the pieces come apart, this is another SIDS problem that can be avoided.

Dishwasher safe pacifiers are also recommended, or just washable ones.

A pacifier should be washed regularly in order to avoid the growth of bacteria, which could cause infections for the baby.

Final Thoughts on the Best Pacifier for New Born

In this article, we explored the different options of pacifiers for a newborn baby as well as establishing in detail the major things that should be considered in our helpful buyer’s guide.

We hope this guide has been helpful in deciding what the best new born pacifier is for you and your baby.

And if you’re looking for more great guides, make sure to check out these guides on do pacifiers expire and pacifier alternatives.