Best Pacifier For Breastfed Babies

Are you trying to the best pacifiers for breastfed babies?

Then let us help you decide which is best for you and your breastfed baby with our guide to the best pacifiers for breastfed baby!

Whilst there is nothing wrong with comfort nursing, not being able to settle your baby because they want to suckle or nurse can be exhausting.

That’s why many mother’s look towards a pacifier.

However, trying to find a pacifier that your breastfed baby will accept instead of a nipple isn’t always easy.

But, that’s why your here!

We have compiled a list of the best pacifiers for breastfeeding babies, looking at their features, pros, and cons so you can easily find a pacifier that your breastfed baby will love.

To make things easier for you, we have also included a handy buyer’s guide so you know everything you need to know to make the right decision on what pacifier you should get.

And if you love this best pacifier for breastfeeding babies guide, make sure to check out our guides on best preemie pacifiers, how many pacifiers do I need and do pacifiers expire.

This post contains affiliate links. See our full disclosure here

List of 5 Best Pacifier For Breastfed Babies

Best Pacifier for Breastfeeding Babies

1. Evenflo Feeding Balance Pacifier

If you are looking for a pacifier that is able to replicate a nipple, then the Evenflo Feeding Balance pacifier is the one for you.

The great thing about the nipple on this pacifier is that it is a perfect size.

We love the fact that this pacifier has actually been linked to helping babies, who have struggled to latch on, start to breastfeed.

So with this pacifier, you do not have to worry about it having a negative impact on your breastfeeding baby.

Another great thing about this pacifier is that it is comfortable. The material this pacifier is made out of is soft silicone.

This makes it a gentle pacifier for babies to have in their mouths.

Since it is made out of soft silicone, the babies can also chew on this pacifier, which is perfect for helping teething babies.

This pacifier is free of any harmful and toxic chemicals as it is made from 100 percent silicone.

This also means that it is BPA-free. The silicone used to make this pacifier is also food-grade silicone so it is safe to be in your baby’s mouth.

As we mentioned earlier, this pacifier can help babies learn to latch on.

This is because the shape of the nipple encourages the natural position of a baby’s tongue.

With the baby’s tongue in a natural position, they are able to develop their suckling skills, helping them to breastfeed.

You will also be able to get a good few months of use out of this pacifier as it is suitable to use for babies from when they are newborns to when they are 6 months old.

However, once your baby has reached 6 months, you can then go onto the second stage of pacifiers available by Evenflo.

The only negative of this pacifier is that it does not come with a protective cap.

This means it does not come with somewhere to store the pacifier when it is not being used.

Pros

• Free From Harmful Chemicals – This pacifier is made from 100% food-grade silicone which is BPA-free. This means you can give this pacifier to your baby without worrying.
• Helps With Breastfeeding – As well as not disrupting breastfeeding, this pacifier actually helps to promote breastfeeding. This pacifier helps your baby to develop the skills to properly latch on when breastfeeding.
• Age Range – This pacifier can be used for babies until they are 6 months old. This means you will get plenty of usage out of this pacifier.

Cons

• No Protective Cap – This pacifier does not come with a protective cap, in which you can store the pacifier safely when your baby is not using it. This means you would have to buy one separately.

2. Ryan & Rose Cutie-Pat Pacifier

If you are looking for a pacifier that can comfort your baby as well as help with the teething process, this is the pacifier for you.

When babies start to have teeth, they can have a habit of biting when breastfeeding.

In order to help with teething babies, this pacifier was designed to have a beaded handle.

This handle is ideal for babies to chew on as well as hold. However, this pacifier should only be used with babies who do not have teeth.

The age range on this pacifier is newborns up to babies who are 6 months old.

However, some customers have had issues with the nipple of the pacifier, finding it too small at times.

The design of this pacifier was made to keep it easy to clean and safe for your baby.

The entire pacifier is made of 100 percent silicone. To make it easy to clean, this pacifier was made out of one piece of silicone.

This means that there are no awkward gaps between materials you need to worry about cleaning.

Since it is made out of 100 percent silicone, it is also BPA-Free.

One issue is that there is writing on the inside of the pacifiers which some babies might not enjoy the feeling of.

Pros

• Safe For Babies Without Teeth – Since this pacifier is designed specifically for babies who don’t have teeth yet, it is safe to use with your baby.
• Easy Cleaning – This pacifier is very easy to clean since it is made out of one piece. It is also BPA-free so you can feel comfortable giving it to your baby.
• BPA-free – Since this pacifier was made from 100 percent silicone, it doesn’t contain any harmful chemicals.

Cons

• Writing On The Inside – The writing might irritate some babies, meaning they do not take to it. 
• Small Nipple – Older babies might find the nipple on the pacifier to be too small for them.

3. The First Years Gumdrop Newborn Pacifiers

If you are looking for a trustworthy pacifier, then the Gumdrop Newborn pacifier is the one for you.

This pacifier is trusted by hospitals all over, as they are distributed to hospitals. This pacifier is made from one piece of silicone.

This makes the pacifier BPA-free, free from latex, and free from phthalates.

The button part of the pacifier is clear so you can see around the area of your baby’s mouth as they use this pacifier.

The design of this pacifier keeps newborns in mind. The shield part of the pacifier is shaped like a heart.

The aim of this is so that the shield does not block your baby’s nose and they can breathe properly when using this pacifier.

This pacifier also has holes in the shield, which helps to keep the air flowing.

However, there have been accounts of some babies’ fingers getting stuck in these holes.

Pros

• 100 Percent Silicone – This pacifier is made from 100 percent silicone. This means that it is BPA-free, latex-free, and phthalate-free.
• Trustworthy – This pacifier is one that hospitals use regularly, making it very trustworthy.
• Shield Is Shaped Like A Heart – This pacifier has a shield shaped like a heart. This means your baby can breathe properly. It also helps with airflow.

Cons

• Holes In The Shield – There are holes in the shield of this pacifier, which allows the air to flow through. However, babies have got their fingers stuck in these holes.

4. Philips AVENT Soothie Pacifier

If you are looking for a pacifier that is perfect for newborn babies, then the Philips AVENT Soothie pacifier is the one for you.

The great thing about this pacifier is that it has a soft nipple that is gentle on newborn babies’ gums.

The pacifier is made from silicone that is hospital-grade. This means it is strong silicone and is BPA-free. There is also no latex in this pacifier.

One of the best things about this pacifier is that it is budget-friendly. It is also available to buy in a four-pack, so you always have a spare available to use.

However, due to this, it does not come with a protective cover or case.

Pros

• Hospital-grade Silicone – This is a pacifier that is very durable and will last you a long time, 
• Comfortable – The silicone is soft, making this comfortable for newborn babies to use. 
• Budget-friendly – This pacifier is available to buy in a four-pack and is still very affordable. 

Cons

• No Protective Cover – Due to being sold in a pack of four, this pacifier does not come with a case or protective cover, so you would have to buy one separately.

5. Tommee Tippee Breast-Like Pacifier

If you are breastfeeding and bottle-feeding, then a pacifier that is a similar shape to the bottle might be a good idea.

The Tommee Tippee Breast-Like pacifier is a great choice for those who are feeding your baby with a bottle as well.

The pacifier was designed to have the same nipple as a bottle. This means that babies who are used to bottles are less likely to reject this pacifier.

The nipple on this pacifier has also been designed to be like a breast. It is made from silicone so the nipple stretches, which is what makes it breast-like.

The silicone is also free from anything that is harmful and toxic to babies.

However, there is no handle on this pacifier. This means babies who like to hold onto things might not take to this pacifier.

Pros

• Breast-like Nipple – This pacifier has nipples that look like breasts. This means that your baby will feel more secure using this pacifier. It is also easy for them to suck on.
• Made From Safe Materials – This pacifier is made from safe materials such as silicone. These materials are non-toxic and do not contain any chemicals that could harm your baby.
• Bottle-like – This pacifier is designed to be like a feeding bottle. This is great for babies used to a bottle. However, it could also help your baby move on to drinking from a bottle. 

Cons

• Does Not Come With A Handle – As mentioned above, this pacifier does have a nipple, but it does not come with an attached handle. If your baby likes to hold onto things, they may find this difficult.

Best Pacifier For Breastfed Baby Buying Guide

When buying a pacifier for your baby, you want something that will help your baby develop good habits while they are still young.

If you buy a pacifier that isn’t right for your baby, then you may end up having issues later down the line. You should look at the following factors before choosing a pacifier:

Size

You need to make sure that the size of the pacifier fits well in your baby’s mouth.

Some babies have larger mouths than others, so you need to check if the size of the pacifiers is suitable.

The size of the pacifier is important because it can affect how the baby suckles on the pacifier.

A pacifier that is too small, will often fall out of the baby’s mouth. On the other hand, if the pacifier is too big, the baby might gag on it.

This could lead to problems such as getting a sore mouth.

Shape

Some pacifiers come in different shapes. These include round, oval, and teardrop shapes. You need to choose a shape that suits your baby’s face best.

The key to getting a pacifier for a breastfed baby is having the nipple of the pacifier be as close as possible to a real nipple.

Not only should you consider the shape of the nipple, but you should also think about the shape of the shield.

Some pacifiers will have holes in the shields to help with the airflow.

This is important for babies with sensitive skin as the build-up of moisture between the shield and their mouth can cause rashes.

Material

Some pacifiers are made from plastic or rubber. Others are made from silicone. Choose a material that is safe for your baby.

You will also need to consider whether your baby has any latex allergies. Some pacifiers are made with latex, which can cause an allergic reaction.

You also want to make sure that the material you are choosing for your baby will not cause them any harm.

Ensuring that all the materials used to make the pacifier are free from any harsh chemicals is always a good place to start when choosing the correct pacifier.

Longevity Of The Pacifier

When choosing a pacifier, you need to consider how long you plan on using the pacifier. You don’t want to spend money on a pacifier that won’t last.

A lot of first-stage pacifiers can be used until the age of six months. However, there are some that can only be used up until the baby is three months old.

This is completely dependent on what you expect out of the pacifier, but it is something to keep in mind when purchasing one.

FAQs on Pacifiers for Breastfed Babies

Are Pacifiers Safe?

Yes! They are very safe products. Pacifiers are often regarded as one of the safest ways to help soothe crying infants.

As long as you follow the instructions given by the manufacturer, then you shouldn’t have any problems.

Pacifiers are often promoted by doctors to use whilst your baby is going to bed, as it can help to reduce the chance of SIDs.

Of course, when it comes to making sure your baby’s pacifier is safe, you need to make sure it is the right size or age group for your baby.

What Type Of Pacifier Should I Get For A Newborn? 

When it comes to purchasing a pacifier for your newborn baby, it is important that the pacifier is made especially for newborns.

Most pacifiers available at this stage are designed to fit into the baby’s mouth easily as they tend to have a smaller shaped nipple.

It is usually best to get a pacifier that is made from 100 percent silicone for a newborn baby, or it needs to have a soft rubber nipple.

There is the option to have a plastic nipple pacifier, as long as the plastic is soft. Make sure that the pacifier is not made from anything that can be harmful to the baby.

It is also wise to look for a pacifier that has a handle your newborn baby can hold onto. This is because newborns like to grip onto things.

Does Using A Pacifier Make Breastfeeding Harder?

Breastfeeding mothers are often told to avoid using pacifiers as it can make breastfeeding harder.

However, this is not always the case. There are plenty of pacifiers that can actually make breastfeeding easier.

Pacifiers help babies learn how to suckle properly which can help them learn to latch on.

This is why getting a pacifier for a baby that is struggling to breastfeed can be a great idea.

Babies who are already breastfeeding should not be affected by adding a pacifier into their routine.

When Do I Need To Change My Baby’s Pacifier?

There are different times when you might need to change your baby’s pacifier.

In terms of when you need to change it daily, this would be anytime you set the pacifier down, any time your baby has dropped the pacifier on the floor, or whenever you feel it needs to be sanitized again.

In terms of changing your baby’s pacifier for a new one, this should be done when your baby has outgrown the pacifier.

Most pacifiers in the first stage can be used until the baby is 6 months old.

However, some require you to change the pacifier once your baby has started to get teeth.

In order to be sure, it is best to check with the manufacturer.

Final Thoughts on Best Pacifier for Breastfeeding Baby

In this article, we explored the different options of pacifiers for a breastfed baby as well as establishing in detail the major things that should be considered in our helpful buyer’s guide.

We hope this guide has been helpful in deciding what the best breastfeeding pacifier is for you and your baby.

And if you’re looking for more great guides, make sure to check out these guides on best pacifiers for newborns, best bottles for breastfed babies, and pacifier alternatives.