Baby Bjorn Vs Ergo Baby Carrier

Trying to decide between Baby Bjorn vs Ergo baby carrier?

Then let us help you decide which is the best baby carrier for you with our detailed comparison guide on Baby Bjorn vs Ergo.

Baby carriers are fantastic for parents who want to be able to move around with their babies, whether that is taking a walk around the neighborhood or getting chores done around the house. However, since carriers have a higher price tag than other baby gear items, you need to do your research, and parents often have the Ergo Baby vs Baby Bjorn carrier debate.

These carriers share many similarities, but they also have critical differences in helping parents choose the best for their baby. Comparing the two may seem challenging but understanding how they differ allows you to pick a suitable carrier.

Not all carriers are the same, and not all will work for your situation. For example, while Ergo Baby and Baby Bjorn are both safe, hip-healthy carriers, they have key differences that make one more ideal for smaller babies and one more suitable for toddlers. However, both work for newborns up to toddlers.

So, let’s dive into what you should know about the differences between the Ergo baby carrier vs Baby Bjorn baby carrier.

And if you love this guide on baby Ergo vs Baby Bjorn, make sure to check out these guide on best baby carriers for breastfeeding, best baby carriers for hot weather, and baby carriers vs wraps. Or even our guide on the best baby carrier for newborn!

This post contains affiliate links. See our full disclosure here

Baby Bjorn Vs Ergo Baby Carrier

Both Ergobaby and Baby Bjorn make fantastic products, and they have a range of carriers to pick from. However, for this comparison article, we are looking at their leading carriers: the Ergobaby Omni 360 and Baby Bjorn One.

All About Ergo Baby Carrier

Ergo Baby is a famous brand amongst mothers, and their Omni 360 is their leading model, combining all of the favorite features of their previous designs. In addition, it allows parents to wear their baby in all carrying positions, including forward-facing. So, you also have the correct position for whatever situation you want.

Unlike previous designs, the Ergo Baby Omni 360 allows you to carry a newborn without an infant insert required. The weight limits are 7 to 45 pounds; It grows with your baby from newborn up to toddlerhood with adjustable side panels that grow with your baby. These panels also allow you to customize the fit of the carrier depending on the carrier position and your baby’s size.

Ergobaby focuses on the parent’s comfort as well. The shoulder straps have two options: crossed or backpack style. Crossing the shoulder straps across your back in an X shape is excellent for weight distribution as your child gets heavier. Added lumbar support on your back also prevents excess strain.

Ergobaby added other features that parents love to see. For example, the Omni 360 comes with a baby hood for sun protection and head support while napping – it also gives you more privacy while breastfeeding – and a detachable storage pouch to keep diapers or other small items.

If you live in a hot climate, consider grabbing the Ergobaby Omni 360 Cool Air Mesh. It has all of the features you love from the Omni 260 with soft mesh for increased breathability.

Pros

• Multiple Carrying Positions
• No Infant Insert Needed
• Included Baby Hood
• Added Lumbar Support
• Great for Breastfeeding
• Used Up to 4 Years Old

Cons

• It May Be Hard to Buckle on Your Own
• Tricky to Use Back Carry Without Help

All About Baby Bjorn Carrier

Baby Bjorn started as a family-owned business over 60 years ago, creating products for families to help with their everyday tasks. Their brand actively encourages fathers to participate in their children’s upbringing and generally design gender-neutral baby gear.

Their Baby Bjorn One is meant to grow with your baby until three years old, with weight limits from 8 lbs to 33lbs. So it’s safe for newborns without needing an infant insert all the way up to three years old. It has adjustable head support, but some parents note it’s not entirely adjustable like other carriers.

Baby Bjorn added a wide, adjustable seat for this carrier that will grow with your baby from birth to toddlerhood. It allows you to carry your baby in four positions: newborn, inward-facing, forward-facing, and back carry. If you had other Baby Bjorn carriers, this is their first carrier with a back carry option.

One unique feature that parents love about the Baby Bjorn One is the harness function. This function allows parents to put the carrier on completely and securely before placing their baby into the harness. It also allows you to remove your baby without taking off your shoulder straps.

Convenient!

Parents often note that they feel unsteady or uncomfortable placing their infants into carriers while trying to attach them. The harness function gives you a stronger sense of security since you won’t need to put on the shoulder straps while continuing to support your infant.

This harness also allows you to switch your baby from front carry to back carry easily. Since your baby is secure in the carrier, you must adjust your shoulder straps.

If you live in a hot climate, you may love the Baby Bjorn One Air, a variation with a mesh design to increase breathability.

Pros

• Four Carrying Positions
• No Infant Insert Needed
• Adjustable Seat & Head Support
• Independent Harness for Ease of Use
• Easy to Use

Cons

• No Baby Hood
• Harder for Breastfeeding
• Lower Weight Limit

Similarities and Differences Between Ergobaby versus Baby Bjorn

Ease of Use

When comparing the Ergo Baby Omni 360 and Baby Bjorn One, both baby carriers are easy to get on and off, but they are different.

The Baby Bjorn goes over your head, like slipping on a t-shirt before strapping the waistband with buckles. After these two steps, you place your baby into the carrier seat and attach the clips to the harness.

The Ergo Baby Omni 360 is similar to all other soft structured carriers. You buckle the waistband, place your baby into the seat, and secure the shoulder straps as you support your baby. It may sound not very easy, but in most cases, it is relatively simple and only takes seconds.

However, parents comment that the added harness makes the Baby Bjorn easier for new parents to use and feels more secure. In addition, all the buckles attaching the carrier to you are in place before putting your baby into the carrier. Something to note is that the Baby Bjorn buckles aren’t common pinch-to-open latches, adding an extra layer of security.

Since parents must reach behind their heads to snap the buckles at their upper back, some find this more different because it requires flexibility. However, the key to making this easier is to loosen the shoulder straps, allowing you to reach the back strap. Then, tighten once all buckles are in place.

When it comes to back carrying, the Baby Bjorn makes it easier because your baby is secure in the harness. You can turn the carrier around, but the Ergo Baby is a bit more complicated. You may feel you need help to get your baby into a back carry.

Fit

All carriers are comfortable, but it will depend on the person wearing the carrier. However, we can examine different features of both carriers to compare the overall fit and comfort.

Both carriers have adjustability on their side with adjustable waistbands, chest straps, and shoulder straps. The Ergo Baby allows you to wear the straps crossed or straight in a backpack style. Crossed straps are ideal for carrying a heavier child or wearing them for long periods, so this tends to be a more comfortable option.

Ergo Baby also has lumbar support added to the waistband, another feature that helps when carrying heavier children.

Carrying Positions

Both carriers allow parents to have multiple ways to carry their baby forward-facing, inward-facing, back carry, and newborn carrying without an insert. In addition, the Ergo Baby has an additional carrying position – the hip carry – which the Baby Bjorn doesn’t offer parents.

In most cases, parents rarely use the hip carry, but having the option to use another position is a bonus – if you think you’d use it. If not, these carriers are equal regarding available carrying positions.

Nursing Friendly

Breastfeeding mothers will need to consider which carrier is easier for breastfeeding. Hands-free breastfeeding is great for busy moms on the go, and not all carriers are ideal for breastfeeding.

The Ergo Baby Omni 360 is an excellent option for breastfeeding. It has adjustable shoulder straps that allow you to get your baby into the perfect position for nursing, and the included sleeping hood gives extra privacy while nursing.

Some mothers note that the Baby Bjorn is difficult for breastfeeding because of the internal harness located between you and the baby. This creates a barrier that could interfere with finding an ideal nursing position.

However, other moms say they have no problems nursing in the Baby Bjorn One. It doesn’t come with a privacy hood. So, overall, the Ergobaby Omni is more nursing-friendly.

Use with a Newborn

Both Ergobaby Omni 360 and Baby Bjorn One work great with newborn babies with no extra infant insert. In addition, each is certified hip-healthy by the International Hip Dysplasia Institute, so each carrier ensures your baby’s legs are in the proper, ergonomic shape to protect their developing hip joints.

The most significant difference here is that some parents note that Baby Bjorn fits more snugly and has extra newborn fasteners to ensure your baby is secure. On the other hand, the Ergo baby is a bit larger, so the Bjorn may be better for you if you prefer the cozy fit.

Use with a Toddler

Each of these carriers work for toddlers, but they aren’t the same.

The Ergo Baby has a longer life span, designed for toddlers up to four years old. The Baby Born is for children until three years old. 

Both allow you to back carry, the preferred carrying position for toddlers, and while the Baby Bjorn has the added harness for ease of back carrying, the Ergo Baby has a bit of a wider fit. Parents of toddlers often prefer this.

Cleaning

Cleanliness is an important factor with any baby gear item; babies get everything dirty!

Baby Bjorn is a machine-washable carrier, but it has many parts that make it harder to clean. In addition, the reviews say that the cleaning process takes too long, and you have to hang the carrier to dry. So, that takes a long time because of the structure and padding.

Ergo Baby Omni is, by far, easier to clean because all you have to do is put it in the washing machine and then the dryer.

Price

Both carriers have similar price tags, but the retail price for the Baby Bjorn One is slightly higher than the Ergobaby Omni 360.

Final Thoughts on Baby Ergo vs Baby Bjorn

Both of these carriers are similar and great carriers on their own. There is no surprise both have excellent ratings and features parents want to see, so it comes down to the features you prefer and your needs in a carrier.

The Baby Bjorn One is ideal if you want a carrier for a newborn or a smaller baby. It has a snug, cozy feel that parents love, and the harness gives you added security when taking your baby in and out. However, it may not be the top pick if you’re a nursing mother.

If you want a carrier that will last you well into the toddler years, the Ergo Baby Omni 360 is your best bet. It has a longer life span, higher weight limit, and the ability to cross the back straps and add lumbar support.

We hope this helps you decide which carrier is best for you and your baby.

And if you’re looking for more great babywearing guides, then check out these guides on best baby carriers for bad backs, best baby carriers for petite moms, and best baby carriers for plus size moms.